You open the decision email, read through the reports, and then realise something awkward. Reviewer 1 wants the literature review cut in half. Reviewer 2 wants it expanded. Reviewer 1 says your sample is too small to support any conclusions. Reviewer 3 calls it “an admirable piece of fieldwork”. One reviewer recommends minor revisions, another recommends rejection.
You cannot satisfy everyone, and you have been given no instructions on how to choose.
Conflicting reviewer comments are among the most common and most stressful features of peer review, and they are especially daunting for doctoral students and early-career researchers who are publishing for the first time. The good news is that contradictions are rarely fatal. Editors expect them, they have seen them hundreds of times, and a calm, reasoned response to a conflict can actually strengthen your case.
This guide explains why reviewers disagree, how to identify the different kinds of conflict, how to decide whose advice to follow, when to ask the editor for help, and exactly how to word your response so that every reviewer feels heard. It is part of our wider series on responding to reviewers, and it works best alongside our guides on how to respond to major revisions and how to disagree with a reviewer politely.
If you would like an experienced editor to analyse the reports with you, our reviewer comments analysis service does exactly that.
Why reviewers disagree in the first place
Understanding why contradictions happen makes them easier to handle. Reviewers are not coordinated. Each one reads your paper independently, usually without seeing the others’ reports, and each brings a different background, set of priorities and level of tolerance to the task.
Different expertise. One reviewer may be a specialist in your method, another in your topic, and a third in your discipline more broadly. A methodologist will scrutinise the analysis; a subject expert will focus on the literature and the argument. Their concerns naturally diverge.
Different expectations about the journal. Reviewers carry their own mental picture of what the journal publishes. One may think the paper is too narrow for a general readership; another may think it is too broad for a specialist title.
Different reading conditions. Reviewers are volunteers who fit the work around teaching, grant writing and their own research. A rushed reader may misunderstand something that a careful one would not.
Different stylistic preferences. A great deal of reviewer feedback is simply taste: how long the introduction should be, how much theory is enough, whether to report effect sizes or confidence intervals, whether the discussion should be more speculative or more cautious.
Different views on the central claim. In contested fields, reviewers sometimes take opposing positions on the question your paper addresses. A reviewer sympathetic to your framework will read your argument charitably; one who favours a rival framework will push back.
Different thresholds. One reviewer may recommend major revisions for the same issues that another treats as minor. This is why you sometimes receive wildly different recommendations from reviewers who appear to have noticed similar things.
None of this reflects badly on you. It is a feature of a system that relies on human judgement.
What the editor is actually doing
Before deciding how to handle a conflict, it helps to know what the editor has already done. The handling editor has read all the reports, and in most cases has read your manuscript too. Their decision letter is the key document.
Editors typically do one of three things with conflicting reviews.
They give explicit guidance. A good editor will often say something like, “Reviewers 1 and 2 disagree on the length of the literature review. I suggest you follow Reviewer 2’s advice and retain the current structure.” If you have such a sentence, follow it. It is the most authoritative instruction you will receive.
They highlight priorities. The editor may say which concerns are essential and which are optional. A concern marked as essential outranks a conflicting suggestion from another reviewer.
They say nothing. Some editors simply forward the reports and leave you to work it out. In that case, you need a method, and the rest of this guide provides one.
Read the editor’s letter before the reviews, and again after. It frames everything else. We explain this in more detail in our guide to responding to major revisions.
The main types of conflicting reviewer comments
Not every conflict is the same, and the right response depends on the type. These are the categories you are most likely to meet.
Direct contradictions
One reviewer asks for something, and another asks for the opposite. Examples include “shorten the introduction” versus “expand the introduction”, “remove Table 2” versus “add more tables”, and “use a qualitative approach” versus “the paper would benefit from a quantitative approach”.
These are the easiest to spot and often the easiest to resolve, because the right answer usually depends on what best serves the paper’s argument and the journal’s readers.
Conflicting recommendations
Reviewer 1 recommends acceptance with minor revisions, Reviewer 2 recommends major revisions, and Reviewer 3 recommends rejection. The editor has already weighed these in reaching their decision, so the recommendation itself is not something you can change. What you can do is respond to the substance behind each recommendation, particularly the points that drove the harshest verdict.
Conflicting interpretations of your findings
One reviewer thinks your results show X, another thinks they show Y. This often signals that your discussion is ambiguous. Clarify your interpretation, acknowledge the alternative, and explain why you favour your reading.
Conflicting methodological demands
One reviewer wants a different statistical test; another is happy with the one you used. One wants a larger sample; another says the sample is adequate. Methodological conflicts need careful handling, because they often involve technical expertise that the editor may not share.
Conflicting framing or scope
One reviewer wants a broader paper that engages with a wider body of theory. Another wants a tight, focused contribution. Scope conflicts depend on what the journal publishes and what you want the paper to achieve.
A reviewer who contradicts the journal’s own guidelines
Occasionally a reviewer asks for something that the author guidelines prohibit: a longer abstract than the limit allows, extra figures beyond the maximum, or a reference style the journal does not use. Here the guidelines win, and you can say so politely.
A reviewer who contradicts the evidence
Sometimes a reviewer simply makes a factual error, or misreads a table. If another reviewer has read the same material correctly, the conflict will be clear. You can point out the correct reading, politely, and quote the relevant passage.
A step-by-step method for handling conflicting comments
When you spot a contradiction, do not try to solve it in your head. Follow this method.
Map the conflicts
Build a response matrix with every comment, as described in our major revisions guide. Add a column called “conflicts with” and note any comment that contradicts another. Seeing the conflicts laid out in a table often makes them much less overwhelming. You may find that what looked like a dozen disagreements is really three.
Check for apparent rather than real conflicts
Some contradictions disappear on closer reading. Reviewer 1 says “the methods are too brief”, while Reviewer 2 says “the methods section is too long”. On closer inspection, Reviewer 1 may be asking for detail about the sampling and Reviewer 2 may be objecting to a long discussion of the software used. Both can be satisfied: add the sampling detail and cut the software discussion.
Always ask: is there a version of the paper that responds to both reviewers’ underlying concerns? Often there is, because the underlying concerns are compatible even when the literal requests are not.
Identify the underlying concern behind each request
Ask what each reviewer is actually worried about. A reviewer who says “expand the literature review” may be worried that you have missed a key debate. A reviewer who says “shorten the literature review” may be worried that the paper takes too long to get to your contribution. Both concerns can be met by restructuring: keep a focused review of the key debates and move supporting detail to a supplementary file or a later section.
Weigh the reviewers’ expertise on the specific point
Not all reviewer opinions carry equal weight on every issue. If a statistician and a subject specialist disagree about a statistical test, the statistician’s view generally deserves more weight. If they disagree about whether you have cited the right theoretical literature, the subject specialist’s view carries more. You can usually work out each reviewer’s strengths from the way they write and what they focus on.
Be careful, though. Never dismiss a reviewer because you think they are less expert. Say, if you need to, that you have weighed the two views and found one better supported by the evidence.
Check what the editor has signalled
Re-read the editor’s letter. Has the editor emphasised one reviewer’s concerns? Has the editor said that a particular point is essential? Has the editor dismissed a point as minor? These signals break ties.
Consider the journal’s readership and scope
Look at recent articles in the journal. Do they have long or short introductions? Do they use mixed methods? What is the typical length? A conflict about structure or style can often be resolved by following the journal’s own norms.
Decide and document
Once you have decided what to do, record the decision in your matrix with a clear rationale. This is the reasoning you will use in your response letter.
Test your decision with a co-author or supervisor
Before committing, discuss the conflicts with someone who knows the field. A supervisor, a co-author or a trusted colleague will often see an obvious resolution you have missed, or confirm that you are on the right track.
When to ask the editor for guidance
Sometimes the right move is to ask. Editors are generally happy to clarify, particularly when the conflict is substantial and the choice affects the structure or direction of the paper.
Ask when the conflict concerns something major: for example, one reviewer wants you to add an entire new study, while another says the paper should be shorter and more focused.
Ask when the conflict is technical and you are not sure which expert is correct.
Ask when the editor’s letter does not give guidance and the choice will take significant time.
Do not ask when the conflict is minor or stylistic. Make your own decision, justify it, and move on.
How to ask
Keep it short, polite and specific. Write a brief email to the editor, ideally through the journal’s submission system or to the editorial office, that does the following:
- States which comments conflict, with reviewer and comment numbers.
- Explains briefly what each reviewer wants.
- Sets out your proposed resolution.
- Asks whether the editor is content with that approach.
An example:
Dear Dr [Surname],
Thank you for your decision on manuscript [number]. We are preparing the revision and would value your guidance on one point. Reviewer 1 (comment 4) recommends removing the comparison with [Country B] to sharpen the focus of the paper, while Reviewer 3 (comment 2) asks for that comparison to be developed further. We propose to retain the comparison but present it in a shorter, clearly signposted section, supported by a supplementary table. Please let us know if you would prefer a different approach.
With thanks, [Name]
Most editors reply within a few days. Even if they do not, you have shown that you took the conflict seriously, and you can mention the query in your cover letter.
How to respond in your letter
Your response letter needs to show that you have noticed the conflict, considered both views, and made a reasoned choice. Here are the principles.
Acknowledge the conflict openly
Do not pretend it is not there. Tell each reviewer that another reviewer raised a different view, and explain what you have done. Reviewers are more likely to accept a decision that goes against their suggestion if they can see that you had a good reason.
Be consistent across responses
If you resolve a conflict one way in Reviewer 1’s response, say the same thing in Reviewer 2’s response. Do not tell one reviewer you followed their advice and tell another that you followed theirs. Cross-refer when helpful.
Give a clear rationale
Explain why you chose one path. Good reasons include the editor’s guidance, the journal’s scope, the strength of the evidence, a methodological argument, a citation to relevant literature or an appeal to the paper’s core aim.
Show a compromise where possible
Where you can partly satisfy both reviewers, say so. Compromises are persuasive because they show goodwill and creativity.
Keep the tone respectful
Never say that one reviewer is wrong and the other right. Say that the reviewers took different views, and explain how you resolved them.
Worked examples
Example 1: Opposing requests about length
Reviewer 1 comment: “The literature review is too long and delays the contribution.”
Reviewer 2 comment: “The literature review needs to be expanded to include recent work on X.”
Response to Reviewer 1:
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We note that Reviewer 2 asked for the literature review to be expanded in one area (see our response to Reviewer 2, comment 3). To address both concerns, we have shortened the general background (pages 3 to 4) and introduced the key debates more concisely, while adding a short subsection on X (page 5, lines 98 to 120). This brings the contribution forward without losing the necessary context.
Response to Reviewer 2:
We are grateful for this suggestion. Reviewer 1 raised a concern about the overall length of the literature review (see our response to Reviewer 1, comment 2). We have therefore added a concise subsection on recent work on X (page 5, lines 98 to 120), and shortened the general background to keep the review focused.
Example 2: Opposing methodological advice
Reviewer 1 comment: “A mixed-effects model would be more appropriate than the repeated-measures ANOVA used here.”
Reviewer 2 comment: “The statistical analysis is appropriate and clearly reported.”
Response to Reviewer 1:
We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. We have re-run the analysis using a linear mixed-effects model with participant as a random effect (Methods, page 8, lines 170 to 182; Results, Table 3). The conclusions are unchanged. We have retained the original ANOVA as a supplementary analysis (Supplementary Table S2), since another reviewer found it appropriate, and so that readers can compare the two approaches.
This response honours both reviewers, shows the work, and is transparent about the outcome.
Example 3: A direct clash with no compromise
Reviewer 1 comment: “The paper should focus exclusively on the UK context.”
Reviewer 2 comment: “The comparison with other European countries is the most valuable part of the paper.”
Response to Reviewer 1:
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and appreciate the concern about focus. However, as Reviewer 2 noted, the comparative element is central to the paper’s contribution, and the editor has indicated that the comparative framing is within the journal’s scope. We have retained the comparison but clarified in the Introduction (page 2, lines 40 to 52) that the UK is the primary case and the other countries serve as points of contrast. We have also made the UK findings easier to locate by adding sub-headings in the Results.
Notice how the response explains the choice, makes a concession and changes the text.
Example 4: Conflicting recommendations
If one reviewer recommends rejection and another recommends minor revisions, address the substance of the harshest critique most carefully. You might write, in the cover note:
We are aware that the reviewers reached different overall recommendations. We have taken all of the concerns seriously and have given particular attention to the points raised by Reviewer 2 concerning the study design, which we believe are the most substantive.
This shows the editor you understand where the risk lies.
Common situations and how to handle them
One reviewer is much harsher than the others
Do not ignore the harsh reviewer. Look past the tone and ask what is substantive. Often a sharp review contains one or two valid points amid the criticism. Address those thoroughly, answer the rest politely, and let the editor see that you have done so.
One reviewer asks for something you consider unreasonable
Explain why, politely, with evidence. For example, if a reviewer asks for a new dataset, explain what you can and cannot do within the scope of the study and add the limitation to the discussion. The editor will usually be on your side if your reasoning is sound and you have made a good-faith effort.
One reviewer’s suggestion would make the paper worse
You are allowed to say so, with care. Use language such as “we considered this suggestion carefully, but we believe it would conflict with the aim of the paper, which is…” and then offer an alternative that addresses the concern.
Reviewers disagree about the paper’s contribution
This often means the framing is unclear. Revisit the abstract, introduction and conclusion. State the contribution plainly and early. If different reviewers see different contributions, make the intended one explicit.
Reviewers disagree about which literature to cite
Cite what is relevant, and avoid padding the reference list with works that are only loosely connected. Where a reviewer suggests their own work, consider it fairly. If it is relevant, cite it; if it is not, explain politely why not. COPE offers guidance on citation manipulation, which is worth reading if you feel pressured to cite for the sake of it.
A reviewer’s comment contradicts the editor
This is rare but can happen. If the editor has given you an instruction and a reviewer asks for something different, follow the editor, and say so. For example: “The editor has advised that X is outside the scope of this revision, and we have therefore not pursued this suggestion.”
Reviewers disagree about ethics or authorship
If the conflict concerns research ethics, authorship or data integrity, do not try to resolve it yourself. Check the guidance from COPE and the ICMJE Recommendations, follow the journal’s policies and consult the editor directly.
Tone and wording: a quick language guide for British academic writing
If you are submitting to UK-based journals or to journals with UK editors, phrasing matters. British academic prose tends to be measured, formally polite and cautious. These phrases work well when handling conflicts.
To acknowledge a conflict:
- “We note that Reviewer 2 raised a different point on this issue.”
- “We recognise that the reviewers hold different views on this matter.”
- “We have taken both views into account.”
To explain a decision:
- “On balance, we have decided to…”
- “In light of the editor’s guidance, we have…”
- “We have sought to address both concerns by…”
To decline a suggestion respectfully:
- “We have considered this suggestion carefully, but…”
- “We respectfully take a different view because…”
- “While we appreciate the intention behind this suggestion, we believe…”
To present a compromise:
- “To meet both concerns, we have…”
- “We have adopted a middle course by…”
The University of Manchester’s Academic Phrasebank is a free, widely used resource with model phrases for contrasting views, acknowledging limitations and presenting reasoned choices. It is a good place to find alternatives to the examples above.
Use British spelling consistently (“analyse”, “behaviour”, “organisation”, “judgement”) and set your word processor to English (UK) before you proofread.
What to avoid when reviewers disagree
Picking the easiest option without explaining why. If you follow one reviewer and ignore the other, say so, with reasons.
Pretending you have followed both when you have not. Reviewers will compare the revision with your letter. A mismatch damages trust.
Playing reviewers off against each other. Never write “Reviewer 2 disagrees with you, so we have ignored your comment”. Present the conflict neutrally and explain your resolution.
Making major structural changes without checking. If a conflict would require a significant change to the paper, ask the editor first.
Hiding the conflict from the editor. Mention significant conflicts in your cover note, so that the editor sees you have handled them thoughtfully.
Ignoring the comments that do not conflict. While you are wrestling with one contradiction, it is easy to neglect the straightforward comments. Every comment needs a response.
Letting emotions drive the decision. If a particular reviewer’s tone upset you, step away and come back before deciding.
Over-complicating the solution. The simplest resolution that respects both reviewers’ concerns is usually the best.
Using reliable resources to support your decisions
When you resolve a conflict, particularly one involving methods, reporting or ethics, it helps to cite an authoritative source. The following are freely available, widely respected and not tied to any commercial service.
- COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) provides guidance on peer review, authorship disputes, conflicts of interest and publication ethics. Useful when a conflict involves an integrity question.
- ICMJE Recommendations set out standards on authorship, disclosure and reporting that many journals follow, within and beyond medicine.
- EQUATOR Network collects reporting guidelines such as CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA and others. If reviewers disagree about how much methodological detail is needed, a reporting guideline can settle the matter.
- Academic Phrasebank (University of Manchester) helps with diplomatic wording.
- Think. Check. Submit. helps you assess whether a journal is trustworthy if you are considering moving your paper elsewhere.
- Sherpa Romeo summarises journal open access and archiving policies, which can inform your choice of venue.
- UKRI and Jisc provide information on UK funder expectations and open access arrangements, relevant if conflicting advice touches on data sharing or licensing.
- Vitae supports UK researcher development and has useful material on publishing and peer review for early-career researchers.
- ORCID provides a persistent researcher identifier that many journals now request at revision stage.
If a reviewer disagreement concerns a reporting standard, name the guideline in your response and attach the completed checklist. It is hard for a reviewer to argue with a recognised standard.
When conflicts affect your next step
Sometimes the extent of the disagreement tells you something about where the paper is heading.
If the editor has invited a revision, the conflicts are manageable. Handle them as above and resubmit.
If the editor has rejected the paper but included conflicting feedback, use the feedback to improve the manuscript before submitting elsewhere. Look for the points both reviewers agree on, because those are the issues any future reviewer is likely to raise. Our guide to what to do after journal rejection covers this in detail.
If you have been asked to “reject and resubmit”, the editor may be asking you to rework the paper substantially. See our explainer on revise and resubmit versus reject and resubmit.
If the conflicts reveal a mismatch between your paper and the journal, consider withdrawing and moving to a journal whose scope fits better. This is a legitimate decision, but make it deliberately and only after checking the journal’s policies on withdrawal.
A short checklist for conflicting reviewer comments
Before you resubmit, check that you have done the following.
- Identified every conflict between reviewers, and between reviewers and the editor.
- Checked whether any apparent contradictions can be resolved by a single change.
- Understood the underlying concern behind each conflicting request.
- Followed the editor’s guidance where it exists.
- Asked the editor for clarification on any major conflict.
- Recorded your decision and rationale for each conflict in the matrix.
- Acknowledged the conflict in each relevant response.
- Kept your explanations consistent across all responses.
- Mentioned significant conflicts in the cover note.
- Supported your decisions with evidence, citations or reporting guidelines.
- Kept the tone courteous and neutral throughout.
- Checked that the revised manuscript reflects what the letter says.
- Proofread everything in British English.
When to get professional support
Handling conflicting reviewer comments is as much about judgement as writing. It can help to have a second opinion if:
- The reports are long, and the conflicts are numerous or technical.
- You are unsure which reviewer’s advice to follow.
- You are working under time pressure.
- English is not your first language, and you want your tone to read as diplomatic and natural.
- The paper is central to a thesis, a promotion case or a grant application and the stakes are high.
At Writers.ng, our editors help researchers analyse reviewer reports, resolve conflicts, plan revisions and write clear, courteous point-by-point responses. Our team can support the whole process, from reviewer comments analysis to rebuttal letter help, major revisions help and manuscript revision and editing. You remain the author of the work and the decision-maker, and we help you present your case as clearly as possible.
Frequently asked questions
What should I do when two reviewers give opposite advice?
Check the editor’s letter for guidance, identify the concern behind each request, look for a solution that satisfies both concerns, and if none exists, choose the option that best serves the paper and explain your reasoning in both responses.
Do I have to follow every reviewer’s advice?
No. You must respond to every comment, but you do not have to do everything a reviewer asks. When you decline a suggestion, give clear reasons and, where possible, make a related change that addresses the concern.
Should I tell the editor about conflicting comments?
Yes, particularly if the conflict is significant. A brief note in your cover letter shows that you have noticed and handled it carefully. For major conflicts, consider emailing the editor before you revise.
What if one reviewer recommends rejection and the others recommend revision?
The editor has already taken this into account in the decision. Focus on the substance of the critical review, answer it thoroughly and politely, and ensure the editor can see that you have taken the strongest concerns seriously.
How do I decide which reviewer is right?
Consider each reviewer’s expertise on the specific point, the strength of their argument and evidence, the editor’s signals, the journal’s scope and the aim of your paper. It is not about who is more senior or who is harsher; it is about which view better serves the work.
Can I ask the editor which reviewer to follow?
Yes. Editors generally welcome a clear, concise query, especially for substantial conflicts. Explain the conflict, propose a solution and ask whether they agree.
What if the editor does not reply?
Make your own decision, document your reasoning, explain it in the response letter and mention in your cover note that you sought guidance. Editors often respond more fully once they see the revised manuscript.
Is it acceptable to follow one reviewer and not the other?
Yes, provided you explain why. Reviewers are more likely to accept a decision they disagree with if it is well reasoned and respectfully stated.
How long should my response be when handling conflicts?
Long enough to explain your decision clearly, and no longer. A few sentences are usually sufficient for each conflicting comment, plus a cross-reference to the other reviewer’s response.
What if the conflicting comments mean I need to restructure the paper?
Discuss with co-authors and, if the change is major, check with the editor. Restructuring can be the best way to satisfy conflicting reviewers, but it must be done carefully so that the paper remains coherent.
Could a reviewer be wrong about something factual?
Yes. If so, quote the relevant passage and explain politely where the information can be found, and consider clarifying the text so that other readers do not make the same mistake.
Can a professional editor help me resolve reviewer conflicts?
Yes. A professional editor can help you analyse the comments, weigh the options, structure your response and polish the language, while you make the scientific decisions and remain responsible for the content. Always follow the journal’s policies on assistance and the guidance from COPE.
Key takeaways
- Conflicting reviewer comments are normal and manageable.
- Start with the editor’s letter; it may already tell you which way to go.
- Map every conflict in a response matrix and look for the concern behind each request.
- Many apparent contradictions can be resolved with a single, carefully designed change.
- When you must choose, choose on the basis of evidence, expertise, scope and the paper’s aim.
- Ask the editor when a conflict is major, technical or unresolved by their letter.
- Acknowledge conflicts openly and keep your answers consistent across responses.
- Keep a respectful, measured tone, especially when declining a suggestion.
- Use authoritative resources to support your decisions.
- Get help when the stakes or the complexity are high.
Need help with conflicting reviewer comments?
If you are facing a pile of contradictory reports and are not sure where to begin, the Writers.ng team can help you make sense of them. We analyse the reviews, identify the real conflicts, recommend a path and help you write a response that editors and reviewers respect.
Visit our response to reviewers service or share your decision letter through our reviewer comments analysis page to get started.
You open the decision email, read through the reports, and then realise something awkward. Reviewer 1 wants the literature review cut in half. Reviewer 2 wants it expanded. Reviewer 1 says your sample is too small to support any conclusions. Reviewer 3 calls it “an admirable piece of fieldwork”. One reviewer recommends minor revisions, another recommends rejection.
You cannot satisfy everyone, and you have been given no instructions on how to choose.
Conflicting reviewer comments are among the most common and most stressful features of peer review, and they are especially daunting for doctoral students and early-career researchers who are publishing for the first time. The good news is that contradictions are rarely fatal. Editors expect them, they have seen them hundreds of times, and a calm, reasoned response to a conflict can actually strengthen your case.
This guide explains why reviewers disagree, how to identify the different kinds of conflict, how to decide whose advice to follow, when to ask the editor for help, and exactly how to word your response so that every reviewer feels heard. It is part of our wider series on responding to reviewers, and it works best alongside our guides on how to respond to major revisions and how to disagree with a reviewer politely.
If you would like an experienced editor to analyse the reports with you, our reviewer comments analysis service does exactly that.
Why reviewers disagree in the first place
Understanding why contradictions happen makes them easier to handle. Reviewers are not coordinated. Each one reads your paper independently, usually without seeing the others’ reports, and each brings a different background, set of priorities and level of tolerance to the task.
Different expertise. One reviewer may be a specialist in your method, another in your topic, and a third in your discipline more broadly. A methodologist will scrutinise the analysis; a subject expert will focus on the literature and the argument. Their concerns naturally diverge.
Different expectations about the journal. Reviewers carry their own mental picture of what the journal publishes. One may think the paper is too narrow for a general readership; another may think it is too broad for a specialist title.
Different reading conditions. Reviewers are volunteers who fit the work around teaching, grant writing and their own research. A rushed reader may misunderstand something that a careful one would not.
Different stylistic preferences. A great deal of reviewer feedback is simply taste: how long the introduction should be, how much theory is enough, whether to report effect sizes or confidence intervals, whether the discussion should be more speculative or more cautious.
Different views on the central claim. In contested fields, reviewers sometimes take opposing positions on the question your paper addresses. A reviewer sympathetic to your framework will read your argument charitably; one who favours a rival framework will push back.
Different thresholds. One reviewer may recommend major revisions for the same issues that another treats as minor. This is why you sometimes receive wildly different recommendations from reviewers who appear to have noticed similar things.
None of this reflects badly on you. It is a feature of a system that relies on human judgement.
What the editor is actually doing
Before deciding how to handle a conflict, it helps to know what the editor has already done. The handling editor has read all the reports, and in most cases has read your manuscript too. Their decision letter is the key document.
Editors typically do one of three things with conflicting reviews.
They give explicit guidance. A good editor will often say something like, “Reviewers 1 and 2 disagree on the length of the literature review. I suggest you follow Reviewer 2’s advice and retain the current structure.” If you have such a sentence, follow it. It is the most authoritative instruction you will receive.
They highlight priorities. The editor may say which concerns are essential and which are optional. A concern marked as essential outranks a conflicting suggestion from another reviewer.
They say nothing. Some editors simply forward the reports and leave you to work it out. In that case, you need a method, and the rest of this guide provides one.
Read the editor’s letter before the reviews, and again after. It frames everything else. We explain this in more detail in our guide to responding to major revisions.
The main types of conflicting reviewer comments
Not every conflict is the same, and the right response depends on the type. These are the categories you are most likely to meet.
Direct contradictions
One reviewer asks for something, and another asks for the opposite. Examples include “shorten the introduction” versus “expand the introduction”, “remove Table 2” versus “add more tables”, and “use a qualitative approach” versus “the paper would benefit from a quantitative approach”.
These are the easiest to spot and often the easiest to resolve, because the right answer usually depends on what best serves the paper’s argument and the journal’s readers.
Conflicting recommendations
Reviewer 1 recommends acceptance with minor revisions, Reviewer 2 recommends major revisions, and Reviewer 3 recommends rejection. The editor has already weighed these in reaching their decision, so the recommendation itself is not something you can change. What you can do is respond to the substance behind each recommendation, particularly the points that drove the harshest verdict.
Conflicting interpretations of your findings
One reviewer thinks your results show X, another thinks they show Y. This often signals that your discussion is ambiguous. Clarify your interpretation, acknowledge the alternative, and explain why you favour your reading.
Conflicting methodological demands
One reviewer wants a different statistical test; another is happy with the one you used. One wants a larger sample; another says the sample is adequate. Methodological conflicts need careful handling, because they often involve technical expertise that the editor may not share.
Conflicting framing or scope
One reviewer wants a broader paper that engages with a wider body of theory. Another wants a tight, focused contribution. Scope conflicts depend on what the journal publishes and what you want the paper to achieve.
A reviewer who contradicts the journal’s own guidelines
Occasionally a reviewer asks for something that the author guidelines prohibit: a longer abstract than the limit allows, extra figures beyond the maximum, or a reference style the journal does not use. Here the guidelines win, and you can say so politely.
A reviewer who contradicts the evidence
Sometimes a reviewer simply makes a factual error, or misreads a table. If another reviewer has read the same material correctly, the conflict will be clear. You can point out the correct reading, politely, and quote the relevant passage.
A step-by-step method for handling conflicting comments
When you spot a contradiction, do not try to solve it in your head. Follow this method.
Map the conflicts
Build a response matrix with every comment, as described in our major revisions guide. Add a column called “conflicts with” and note any comment that contradicts another. Seeing the conflicts laid out in a table often makes them much less overwhelming. You may find that what looked like a dozen disagreements is really three.
Check for apparent rather than real conflicts
Some contradictions disappear on closer reading. Reviewer 1 says “the methods are too brief”, while Reviewer 2 says “the methods section is too long”. On closer inspection, Reviewer 1 may be asking for detail about the sampling and Reviewer 2 may be objecting to a long discussion of the software used. Both can be satisfied: add the sampling detail and cut the software discussion.
Always ask: is there a version of the paper that responds to both reviewers’ underlying concerns? Often there is, because the underlying concerns are compatible even when the literal requests are not.
Identify the underlying concern behind each request
Ask what each reviewer is actually worried about. A reviewer who says “expand the literature review” may be worried that you have missed a key debate. A reviewer who says “shorten the literature review” may be worried that the paper takes too long to get to your contribution. Both concerns can be met by restructuring: keep a focused review of the key debates and move supporting detail to a supplementary file or a later section.
Weigh the reviewers’ expertise on the specific point
Not all reviewer opinions carry equal weight on every issue. If a statistician and a subject specialist disagree about a statistical test, the statistician’s view generally deserves more weight. If they disagree about whether you have cited the right theoretical literature, the subject specialist’s view carries more. You can usually work out each reviewer’s strengths from the way they write and what they focus on.
Be careful, though. Never dismiss a reviewer because you think they are less expert. Say, if you need to, that you have weighed the two views and found one better supported by the evidence.
Check what the editor has signalled
Re-read the editor’s letter. Has the editor emphasised one reviewer’s concerns? Has the editor said that a particular point is essential? Has the editor dismissed a point as minor? These signals break ties.
Consider the journal’s readership and scope
Look at recent articles in the journal. Do they have long or short introductions? Do they use mixed methods? What is the typical length? A conflict about structure or style can often be resolved by following the journal’s own norms.
Decide and document
Once you have decided what to do, record the decision in your matrix with a clear rationale. This is the reasoning you will use in your response letter.
Test your decision with a co-author or supervisor
Before committing, discuss the conflicts with someone who knows the field. A supervisor, a co-author or a trusted colleague will often see an obvious resolution you have missed, or confirm that you are on the right track.
When to ask the editor for guidance
Sometimes the right move is to ask. Editors are generally happy to clarify, particularly when the conflict is substantial and the choice affects the structure or direction of the paper.
Ask when the conflict concerns something major: for example, one reviewer wants you to add an entire new study, while another says the paper should be shorter and more focused.
Ask when the conflict is technical and you are not sure which expert is correct.
Ask when the editor’s letter does not give guidance and the choice will take significant time.
Do not ask when the conflict is minor or stylistic. Make your own decision, justify it, and move on.
How to ask
Keep it short, polite and specific. Write a brief email to the editor, ideally through the journal’s submission system or to the editorial office, that does the following:
- States which comments conflict, with reviewer and comment numbers.
- Explains briefly what each reviewer wants.
- Sets out your proposed resolution.
- Asks whether the editor is content with that approach.
An example:
Dear Dr [Surname],
Thank you for your decision on manuscript [number]. We are preparing the revision and would value your guidance on one point. Reviewer 1 (comment 4) recommends removing the comparison with [Country B] to sharpen the focus of the paper, while Reviewer 3 (comment 2) asks for that comparison to be developed further. We propose to retain the comparison but present it in a shorter, clearly signposted section, supported by a supplementary table. Please let us know if you would prefer a different approach.
With thanks, [Name]
Most editors reply within a few days. Even if they do not, you have shown that you took the conflict seriously, and you can mention the query in your cover letter.
How to respond in your letter
Your response letter needs to show that you have noticed the conflict, considered both views, and made a reasoned choice. Here are the principles.
Acknowledge the conflict openly
Do not pretend it is not there. Tell each reviewer that another reviewer raised a different view, and explain what you have done. Reviewers are more likely to accept a decision that goes against their suggestion if they can see that you had a good reason.
Be consistent across responses
If you resolve a conflict one way in Reviewer 1’s response, say the same thing in Reviewer 2’s response. Do not tell one reviewer you followed their advice and tell another that you followed theirs. Cross-refer when helpful.
Give a clear rationale
Explain why you chose one path. Good reasons include the editor’s guidance, the journal’s scope, the strength of the evidence, a methodological argument, a citation to relevant literature or an appeal to the paper’s core aim.
Show a compromise where possible
Where you can partly satisfy both reviewers, say so. Compromises are persuasive because they show goodwill and creativity.
Keep the tone respectful
Never say that one reviewer is wrong and the other right. Say that the reviewers took different views, and explain how you resolved them.
Worked examples
Example 1: Opposing requests about length
Reviewer 1 comment: “The literature review is too long and delays the contribution.”
Reviewer 2 comment: “The literature review needs to be expanded to include recent work on X.”
Response to Reviewer 1:
We thank the reviewer for this comment. We note that Reviewer 2 asked for the literature review to be expanded in one area (see our response to Reviewer 2, comment 3). To address both concerns, we have shortened the general background (pages 3 to 4) and introduced the key debates more concisely, while adding a short subsection on X (page 5, lines 98 to 120). This brings the contribution forward without losing the necessary context.
Response to Reviewer 2:
We are grateful for this suggestion. Reviewer 1 raised a concern about the overall length of the literature review (see our response to Reviewer 1, comment 2). We have therefore added a concise subsection on recent work on X (page 5, lines 98 to 120), and shortened the general background to keep the review focused.
Example 2: Opposing methodological advice
Reviewer 1 comment: “A mixed-effects model would be more appropriate than the repeated-measures ANOVA used here.”
Reviewer 2 comment: “The statistical analysis is appropriate and clearly reported.”
Response to Reviewer 1:
We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. We have re-run the analysis using a linear mixed-effects model with participant as a random effect (Methods, page 8, lines 170 to 182; Results, Table 3). The conclusions are unchanged. We have retained the original ANOVA as a supplementary analysis (Supplementary Table S2), since another reviewer found it appropriate, and so that readers can compare the two approaches.
This response honours both reviewers, shows the work, and is transparent about the outcome.
Example 3: A direct clash with no compromise
Reviewer 1 comment: “The paper should focus exclusively on the UK context.”
Reviewer 2 comment: “The comparison with other European countries is the most valuable part of the paper.”
Response to Reviewer 1:
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and appreciate the concern about focus. However, as Reviewer 2 noted, the comparative element is central to the paper’s contribution, and the editor has indicated that the comparative framing is within the journal’s scope. We have retained the comparison but clarified in the Introduction (page 2, lines 40 to 52) that the UK is the primary case and the other countries serve as points of contrast. We have also made the UK findings easier to locate by adding sub-headings in the Results.
Notice how the response explains the choice, makes a concession and changes the text.
Example 4: Conflicting recommendations
If one reviewer recommends rejection and another recommends minor revisions, address the substance of the harshest critique most carefully. You might write, in the cover note:
We are aware that the reviewers reached different overall recommendations. We have taken all of the concerns seriously and have given particular attention to the points raised by Reviewer 2 concerning the study design, which we believe are the most substantive.
This shows the editor you understand where the risk lies.
Common situations and how to handle them
One reviewer is much harsher than the others
Do not ignore the harsh reviewer. Look past the tone and ask what is substantive. Often a sharp review contains one or two valid points amid the criticism. Address those thoroughly, answer the rest politely, and let the editor see that you have done so.
One reviewer asks for something you consider unreasonable
Explain why, politely, with evidence. For example, if a reviewer asks for a new dataset, explain what you can and cannot do within the scope of the study and add the limitation to the discussion. The editor will usually be on your side if your reasoning is sound and you have made a good-faith effort.
One reviewer’s suggestion would make the paper worse
You are allowed to say so, with care. Use language such as “we considered this suggestion carefully, but we believe it would conflict with the aim of the paper, which is…” and then offer an alternative that addresses the concern.
Reviewers disagree about the paper’s contribution
This often means the framing is unclear. Revisit the abstract, introduction and conclusion. State the contribution plainly and early. If different reviewers see different contributions, make the intended one explicit.
Reviewers disagree about which literature to cite
Cite what is relevant, and avoid padding the reference list with works that are only loosely connected. Where a reviewer suggests their own work, consider it fairly. If it is relevant, cite it; if it is not, explain politely why not. COPE offers guidance on citation manipulation, which is worth reading if you feel pressured to cite for the sake of it.
A reviewer’s comment contradicts the editor
This is rare but can happen. If the editor has given you an instruction and a reviewer asks for something different, follow the editor, and say so. For example: “The editor has advised that X is outside the scope of this revision, and we have therefore not pursued this suggestion.”
Reviewers disagree about ethics or authorship
If the conflict concerns research ethics, authorship or data integrity, do not try to resolve it yourself. Check the guidance from COPE and the ICMJE Recommendations, follow the journal’s policies and consult the editor directly.
Tone and wording: a quick language guide for British academic writing
If you are submitting to UK-based journals or to journals with UK editors, phrasing matters. British academic prose tends to be measured, formally polite and cautious. These phrases work well when handling conflicts.
To acknowledge a conflict:
- “We note that Reviewer 2 raised a different point on this issue.”
- “We recognise that the reviewers hold different views on this matter.”
- “We have taken both views into account.”
To explain a decision:
- “On balance, we have decided to…”
- “In light of the editor’s guidance, we have…”
- “We have sought to address both concerns by…”
To decline a suggestion respectfully:
- “We have considered this suggestion carefully, but…”
- “We respectfully take a different view because…”
- “While we appreciate the intention behind this suggestion, we believe…”
To present a compromise:
- “To meet both concerns, we have…”
- “We have adopted a middle course by…”
The University of Manchester’s Academic Phrasebank is a free, widely used resource with model phrases for contrasting views, acknowledging limitations and presenting reasoned choices. It is a good place to find alternatives to the examples above.
Use British spelling consistently (“analyse”, “behaviour”, “organisation”, “judgement”) and set your word processor to English (UK) before you proofread.
What to avoid when reviewers disagree
Picking the easiest option without explaining why. If you follow one reviewer and ignore the other, say so, with reasons.
Pretending you have followed both when you have not. Reviewers will compare the revision with your letter. A mismatch damages trust.
Playing reviewers off against each other. Never write “Reviewer 2 disagrees with you, so we have ignored your comment”. Present the conflict neutrally and explain your resolution.
Making major structural changes without checking. If a conflict would require a significant change to the paper, ask the editor first.
Hiding the conflict from the editor. Mention significant conflicts in your cover note, so that the editor sees you have handled them thoughtfully.
Ignoring the comments that do not conflict. While you are wrestling with one contradiction, it is easy to neglect the straightforward comments. Every comment needs a response.
Letting emotions drive the decision. If a particular reviewer’s tone upset you, step away and come back before deciding.
Over-complicating the solution. The simplest resolution that respects both reviewers’ concerns is usually the best.
Using reliable resources to support your decisions
When you resolve a conflict, particularly one involving methods, reporting or ethics, it helps to cite an authoritative source. The following are freely available, widely respected and not tied to any commercial service.
- COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) provides guidance on peer review, authorship disputes, conflicts of interest and publication ethics. Useful when a conflict involves an integrity question.
- ICMJE Recommendations set out standards on authorship, disclosure and reporting that many journals follow, within and beyond medicine.
- EQUATOR Network collects reporting guidelines such as CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA and others. If reviewers disagree about how much methodological detail is needed, a reporting guideline can settle the matter.
- Academic Phrasebank (University of Manchester) helps with diplomatic wording.
- Think. Check. Submit. helps you assess whether a journal is trustworthy if you are considering moving your paper elsewhere.
- Sherpa Romeo summarises journal open access and archiving policies, which can inform your choice of venue.
- UKRI and Jisc provide information on UK funder expectations and open access arrangements, relevant if conflicting advice touches on data sharing or licensing.
- Vitae supports UK researcher development and has useful material on publishing and peer review for early-career researchers.
- ORCID provides a persistent researcher identifier that many journals now request at revision stage.
If a reviewer disagreement concerns a reporting standard, name the guideline in your response and attach the completed checklist. It is hard for a reviewer to argue with a recognised standard.
When conflicts affect your next step
Sometimes the extent of the disagreement tells you something about where the paper is heading.
If the editor has invited a revision, the conflicts are manageable. Handle them as above and resubmit.
If the editor has rejected the paper but included conflicting feedback, use the feedback to improve the manuscript before submitting elsewhere. Look for the points both reviewers agree on, because those are the issues any future reviewer is likely to raise. Our guide to what to do after journal rejection covers this in detail.
If you have been asked to “reject and resubmit”, the editor may be asking you to rework the paper substantially. See our explainer on revise and resubmit versus reject and resubmit.
If the conflicts reveal a mismatch between your paper and the journal, consider withdrawing and moving to a journal whose scope fits better. This is a legitimate decision, but make it deliberately and only after checking the journal’s policies on withdrawal.
A short checklist for conflicting reviewer comments
Before you resubmit, check that you have done the following.
- Identified every conflict between reviewers, and between reviewers and the editor.
- Checked whether any apparent contradictions can be resolved by a single change.
- Understood the underlying concern behind each conflicting request.
- Followed the editor’s guidance where it exists.
- Asked the editor for clarification on any major conflict.
- Recorded your decision and rationale for each conflict in the matrix.
- Acknowledged the conflict in each relevant response.
- Kept your explanations consistent across all responses.
- Mentioned significant conflicts in the cover note.
- Supported your decisions with evidence, citations or reporting guidelines.
- Kept the tone courteous and neutral throughout.
- Checked that the revised manuscript reflects what the letter says.
- Proofread everything in British English.
When to get professional support
Handling conflicting reviewer comments is as much about judgement as writing. It can help to have a second opinion if:
- The reports are long, and the conflicts are numerous or technical.
- You are unsure which reviewer’s advice to follow.
- You are working under time pressure.
- English is not your first language, and you want your tone to read as diplomatic and natural.
- The paper is central to a thesis, a promotion case or a grant application and the stakes are high.
At Writers.ng, our editors help researchers analyse reviewer reports, resolve conflicts, plan revisions and write clear, courteous point-by-point responses. Our team can support the whole process, from reviewer comments analysis to rebuttal letter help, major revisions help and manuscript revision and editing. You remain the author of the work and the decision-maker, and we help you present your case as clearly as possible.
Frequently asked questions
What should I do when two reviewers give opposite advice?
Check the editor’s letter for guidance, identify the concern behind each request, look for a solution that satisfies both concerns, and if none exists, choose the option that best serves the paper and explain your reasoning in both responses.
Do I have to follow every reviewer’s advice?
No. You must respond to every comment, but you do not have to do everything a reviewer asks. When you decline a suggestion, give clear reasons and, where possible, make a related change that addresses the concern.
Should I tell the editor about conflicting comments?
Yes, particularly if the conflict is significant. A brief note in your cover letter shows that you have noticed and handled it carefully. For major conflicts, consider emailing the editor before you revise.
What if one reviewer recommends rejection and the others recommend revision?
The editor has already taken this into account in the decision. Focus on the substance of the critical review, answer it thoroughly and politely, and ensure the editor can see that you have taken the strongest concerns seriously.
How do I decide which reviewer is right?
Consider each reviewer’s expertise on the specific point, the strength of their argument and evidence, the editor’s signals, the journal’s scope and the aim of your paper. It is not about who is more senior or who is harsher; it is about which view better serves the work.
Can I ask the editor which reviewer to follow?
Yes. Editors generally welcome a clear, concise query, especially for substantial conflicts. Explain the conflict, propose a solution and ask whether they agree.
What if the editor does not reply?
Make your own decision, document your reasoning, explain it in the response letter and mention in your cover note that you sought guidance. Editors often respond more fully once they see the revised manuscript.
Is it acceptable to follow one reviewer and not the other?
Yes, provided you explain why. Reviewers are more likely to accept a decision they disagree with if it is well reasoned and respectfully stated.
How long should my response be when handling conflicts?
Long enough to explain your decision clearly, and no longer. A few sentences are usually sufficient for each conflicting comment, plus a cross-reference to the other reviewer’s response.
What if the conflicting comments mean I need to restructure the paper?
Discuss with co-authors and, if the change is major, check with the editor. Restructuring can be the best way to satisfy conflicting reviewers, but it must be done carefully so that the paper remains coherent.
Could a reviewer be wrong about something factual?
Yes. If so, quote the relevant passage and explain politely where the information can be found, and consider clarifying the text so that other readers do not make the same mistake.
Can a professional editor help me resolve reviewer conflicts?
Yes. A professional editor can help you analyse the comments, weigh the options, structure your response and polish the language, while you make the scientific decisions and remain responsible for the content. Always follow the journal’s policies on assistance and the guidance from COPE.
Key takeaways
- Conflicting reviewer comments are normal and manageable.
- Start with the editor’s letter; it may already tell you which way to go.
- Map every conflict in a response matrix and look for the concern behind each request.
- Many apparent contradictions can be resolved with a single, carefully designed change.
- When you must choose, choose on the basis of evidence, expertise, scope and the paper’s aim.
- Ask the editor when a conflict is major, technical or unresolved by their letter.
- Acknowledge conflicts openly and keep your answers consistent across responses.
- Keep a respectful, measured tone, especially when declining a suggestion.
- Use authoritative resources to support your decisions.
- Get help when the stakes or the complexity are high.
Need help with conflicting reviewer comments?
If you are facing a pile of contradictory reports and are not sure where to begin, the Writers.ng team can help you make sense of them. We analyse the reviews, identify the real conflicts, recommend a path and help you write a response that editors and reviewers respect.
Visit our response to reviewers service or share your decision letter through our reviewer comments analysis page to get started.