Response to Reviewers Examples: 14 Sample Replies and a Full Letter (UK Guide)

How to Structure an Academic Assignment: A UK Step-by-Step Guide | Writers.ng

Part of the Response to Reviewers guide from Writers.ng.

A template tells you where things go. An example shows you what to actually say. If you have a stack of reviewer comments in front of you and no idea how to word your replies, this guide is for you.

Below you will find 14 sample replies to the most common types of reviewer comment, a complete sample response letter you can model your own on, and short notes on why each example works. They are written for researchers submitting to UK and international journals, and they cover STEM, social science and humanities situations. Every example is invented for illustration, so adapt the wording to your own data, discipline and journal.

If you have not yet set up your letter’s structure, start with our response to reviewers template and come back here for the wording. If you would rather have an expert draft the replies with you, see our response letter writing service.

Key takeaways

  • A good reply does four things: thanks the reviewer briefly, states what you did, says why, and gives the exact location of the change.
  • You can agree, partly agree, clarify, decline or disagree, but you must always respond.
  • Evidence beats opinion. Cite data, a reference or a policy whenever you push back.
  • Keep replies proportionate. A small comment gets a short reply.
  • Never copy an example word for word. Editors and reviewers can spot generic text.

What makes a good example of a response to reviewers?

Before the samples, it helps to know what editors are looking for. Publisher guidance is consistent on the basics. The American Chemical Society advises authors to respond point by point, quote the review where necessary, respond to every comment even when you disagree, and tell the editor clearly about any suggestion you chose not to follow. See the ACS advice on how to respond to reviewer comments.

A frequently cited article by Professor Hywel Williams of the University of Nottingham sums up the approach in three golden rules: respond completely, respond politely and respond with evidence. You can read it here: How to reply to referees’ comments when submitting manuscripts for publication. Each example below is built around those three rules.

How to read the examples

In each example you will see:

  • The reviewer comment (quoted, as you would paste it into your letter).
  • A weak reply where it helps to show what to avoid.
  • A strong reply with a “Change made” line.
  • Why it works, in a sentence or two.

Page and line numbers are placeholders. In your own letter they must match your final manuscript exactly.

Example 1: The reviewer asks for more literature

Comment 1.1: The literature review overlooks recent work on remote assessment in higher education. The authors should engage with this research.

Weak reply: “We have added some references.”

Strong reply:

Response: Thank you for this helpful point. We agree that the review of recent literature on remote assessment was thin. We have added a new paragraph to the Literature Review that discusses [Author, Year], [Author, Year] and [Author, Year], and explains how our study extends their findings to postgraduate cohorts. We have also updated the Discussion to compare our results with theirs.

Change made: Literature Review, page 4, lines 22 to 35; Discussion, page 13, lines 7 to 12; References, pages 20 to 21.

Why it works: It names the new sources, shows how they are used, and gives three locations. Adding references to a list without integrating them into the argument is a common reason for a second round of criticism.

Example 2: The reviewer questions your methodology

Comment 1.2: The sampling approach is not clearly justified. Why were participants recruited from only two institutions?

Strong reply:

Response: We appreciate this question. We recruited from two institutions because they represent the two most common models of provision in our population (a research-intensive university and a teaching-focused university). We had not made this rationale explicit and have now done so. We have also added the recruitment limitations to the Limitations section and softened claims about generalisability.

Change made: Methods, Section 3.1, page 7, lines 3 to 11; Limitations, page 15, lines 4 to 9; Abstract, line 14 (“suggests” replaces “shows”).

Why it works: The author concedes that the original text was unclear, gives the reasoning, then changes the claims to fit the evidence. That shows good judgement rather than defensiveness.

Example 3: The reviewer challenges your statistics

Comment 2.1: The authors use multiple t-tests without correcting for multiple comparisons. This inflates the risk of false positives.

Strong reply:

Response: Thank you for catching this. We agree that multiple comparisons required correction. We have re-run the analysis using a Bonferroni correction. The main effect remains significant ([statistic], p = [value]), but two of the secondary comparisons are no longer significant and we now report them as exploratory. Table 3 and the Results text have been updated, and the Methods now describe the correction.

Change made: Methods, Section 2.5, page 6, lines 18 to 22; Results, Section 4.2, page 10, lines 1 to 14; Table 3, page 11.

Why it works: Honest reporting of the changed result builds trust. Editors respect authors who show that results survived (or did not survive) a tougher test.

Example 4: The reviewer says the writing is unclear

Comment 1.3: The Introduction is hard to follow and the research question is not stated until page 5.

Strong reply:

Response: We apologise that the aims were not clear. We have restructured the Introduction so that the research problem appears in the first paragraph, the gap in the literature follows, and the research question and hypotheses are stated at the end of page 2. We also asked a colleague outside the project to read the section, and have simplified several long sentences following their feedback.

Change made: Introduction, pages 2 to 4 (substantially rewritten; see tracked changes).

Why it works: For a broad comment, it describes what was restructured and where. Where changes are extensive, it directs the editor to the tracked-changes file instead of pasting pages of text.

Example 5: The reviewer asks for new data you cannot collect

Comment 2.2: The study would be much stronger with a follow-up survey after six months.

Strong reply:

Response: We agree that longitudinal data would add valuable insight into whether the effects persist. Unfortunately, the project ended in [month, year], the funding has expired and our ethical approval did not cover re-contact with participants, so a follow-up is not possible. We have acknowledged this explicitly as a limitation and framed the findings as short-term effects. We have also proposed a longitudinal design in the Future Research section.

Change made: Limitations, page 15, lines 10 to 16; Future Research, page 16, lines 1 to 6; Abstract, line 17.

Why it works: It does not just say “no”. It gives a concrete, honest reason, shows what was done instead and turns the request into a future research direction.

Example 6: The reviewer misunderstood your paper

Comment 1.4: The authors claim that the intervention caused the improvement, but there is no control group.

Strong reply:

Response: Thank you for raising this. We can see how our wording suggested a causal claim, which we did not intend. The study used a quasi-experimental design with a matched comparison group (described in Section 2.2), but we did not make this prominent enough. We have moved the description of the comparison group to the start of the Methods, added a flow diagram (new Figure 1) and replaced causal language such as “caused” with “was associated with” throughout.

Change made: Methods, Section 2.2, page 5, lines 4 to 16; new Figure 1, page 6; causal wording revised on pages 1, 9, 12 and 14.

Why it works: It assumes the problem is a clarity problem (“we can see how our wording suggested…”) and avoids saying the reviewer failed to read properly. This is one of the most effective habits in the whole process.

Example 7: You disagree with the reviewer

Comment 2.3: The authors should use structural equation modelling instead of regression.

Weak reply: “We disagree. Regression is appropriate.”

Strong reply:

Response: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and have considered it carefully. We respectfully retained regression for two reasons. First, with 112 participants our sample is below commonly recommended thresholds for stable structural equation models ([Author, Year]). Second, our research question concerns the relationship between two observed variables rather than latent constructs, which does not require a measurement model. To address the underlying concern about model specification, we have added robustness checks using alternative covariates (Appendix B) and noted the potential value of structural modelling with a larger sample in the Limitations.

Change made: Methods, page 6, lines 25 to 31; new Appendix B, pages 24 to 25; Limitations, page 15, lines 17 to 20.

Why it works: The author gives two evidence-based reasons, cites the literature, and offers something in return (the robustness check). The editor sees a considered decision, not stubbornness. For more on this skill, read our post on how to disagree with a reviewer politely.

Example 8: The reviewers contradict each other

Comment 1.5 (Reviewer 1): The Discussion is too long and should be shortened. Comment 2.4 (Reviewer 2): The Discussion should engage more deeply with theoretical implications.

Strong reply (addressed to the editor):

Response: We note that Reviewers 1 and 2 made opposing requests about the Discussion. We have tried to meet both concerns by shortening the descriptive recap of results by about 300 words (Reviewer 1) and using the space to add a more focused section on theoretical implications (Reviewer 2). The overall length of the Discussion is therefore roughly unchanged. We would be happy to adjust this balance if the editor prefers a different approach.

Change made: Discussion, pages 12 to 14 (see tracked changes).

Why it works: It names the conflict openly, explains the compromise and invites the editor’s guidance. Our guide to conflicting reviewer comments covers more scenarios.

Example 9: The reviewer asks about the novelty or contribution

Comment 1.6: The contribution of this paper beyond existing studies is not clear.

Strong reply:

Response: We appreciate this challenge. We have clarified the contribution in three ways. First, the final paragraph of the Introduction now states explicitly that this is the first study to examine [topic] in [population or setting]. Second, we have added a short table comparing our study with the five most closely related papers (new Table 1). Third, the Discussion now ends with a paragraph on implications for practice and policy.

Change made: Introduction, page 3, lines 28 to 36; new Table 1, page 4; Discussion, page 14, lines 20 to 30.

Why it works: A numbered answer to a big question is easy to scan, and the comparison table gives the reviewer concrete proof of novelty.

Example 10: The reviewer questions your conclusions

Comment 2.5: The conclusions go beyond what the data support.

Strong reply:

Response: We agree that some of our conclusions were stronger than the evidence warrants. We have revised the Conclusion and Abstract to make clear that our findings are exploratory and limited to the sample studied. Statements about policy implications have been replaced with more cautious suggestions for future research.

Change made: Abstract, lines 15 to 19; Conclusion, page 16, lines 1 to 14.

Why it works: Reviewers often reward restraint. Reducing an overstated claim is usually easier, and more persuasive, than defending it.

Example 11: The reviewer asks for language or English editing

Comment 2.6: The manuscript would benefit from careful English language editing.

Strong reply:

Response: Thank you. We have revised the whole manuscript for clarity, grammar and style, shortened long sentences and standardised terminology (for example, we now use “participants” throughout rather than alternating between “subjects” and “respondents”). The revised version has also been proofread by a professional academic editor.

Change made: Throughout the manuscript (see tracked changes).

Why it works: It is specific about what was fixed, so the reviewer knows the comment was taken seriously. If you need that kind of polish, our manuscript revision and editing service is designed for this stage.

Example 12: The reviewer wants a better figure or table

Comment 1.7: Figure 2 is difficult to read and the axes are not labelled.

Strong reply:

Response: We agree. We have redrawn Figure 2 with larger fonts, labelled axes (including units), a legend and a colour-blind-friendly palette. The caption now explains each panel so that the figure can be understood without reference to the text.

Change made: Figure 2 and caption, page 9.

Why it works: Small, concrete comments deserve short, concrete replies. There is no need for more than a few lines.

Example 13: The comment is harsh or dismissive

Comment 2.7: This paper adds nothing new and the authors clearly have not read the field.

This kind of comment hurts, and it is tempting to respond in kind. Do not. Look for the legitimate concern inside it, answer that and ignore the tone. Peer review has ethical standards on the reviewer’s side too: the Committee on Publication Ethics publishes ethical guidelines for peer reviewers and wider core practices which journals follow, and editors know that personal criticism is inappropriate. You do not have to complain about it. Your job is to be professional.

Weak reply: “This comment is unfair and unprofessional.”

Strong reply:

Response: We thank the reviewer for the feedback and understand that the contribution was not sufficiently clear. We have expanded the Literature Review to engage with the key work in the area, including [Author, Year], [Author, Year] and [Author, Year], and added a short paragraph at the end of the Introduction explaining how our study differs from this earlier work.

Change made: Literature Review, pages 3 to 5; Introduction, page 3, lines 30 to 38.

Why it works: The reply treats the review as a request for clarification and answers it calmly. If you believe a review was truly abusive or discriminatory, raise it with the editor in a separate, polite note rather than in the response letter. Elsevier’s Researcher Academy webinar by a publisher, How to respond to reviewers’ comments, discusses tone and language and is worth watching if you feel stuck.

Example 14: The editor asks for a structural change

Editor’s comment E1: Please reduce the manuscript to 6,000 words, including references, in line with the journal’s guidelines.

Strong reply:

Response: Thank you for drawing our attention to the word limit. We have reduced the manuscript from 7,450 to 5,980 words by condensing the Literature Review, removing duplicated material between the Results and Discussion, and moving two tables to the online supplementary file.

Change made: Throughout the manuscript; supplementary Tables S1 and S2 are provided as a separate file.

Why it works: Editors’ comments are not optional. Reply first, and make it easy to confirm that you complied.

A complete sample response letter

Here is a short, complete letter showing how the pieces fit together. It is invented for illustration. Use it as a model for structure and tone, not as text to copy.

Response to Reviewers

Manuscript title: Student Engagement in Online Postgraduate Courses: A Mixed-Methods Study Manuscript ID: [ID] Journal: [Journal name]

Dear Dr Patel and Reviewers,

Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript and for the constructive comments. We have addressed each point below. Reviewer comments are in bold, our responses are in plain text and revised manuscript text is in italics. Page and line numbers refer to the revised manuscript with tracked changes.

Summary of the main changes

  1. We justified the sampling strategy and clarified the study design (Methods, Section 2).
  2. We corrected the statistical analysis for multiple comparisons (Results, Section 4).
  3. We expanded the Literature Review and clarified the contribution (Introduction and Literature Review).
  4. We moderated claims in the Abstract, Discussion and Conclusion.

Reviewer 1

We thank Reviewer 1 for the careful reading and helpful suggestions.

Comment 1.1: The sampling approach is not clearly justified.

Response: Thank you. We have added the rationale for recruiting from two institutions that represent different provision models, and acknowledged the limited generalisability. “We recruited from two institutions representing…”

Change made: Methods, Section 2.1, page 5, lines 3 to 11; Limitations, page 14, lines 4 to 8.

Comment 1.2: The Introduction does not state the research question clearly.

Response: We agree and have restructured the Introduction so that the research question appears at the end of page 2.

Change made: Introduction, pages 2 to 3.

Reviewer 2

Comment 2.1: Multiple t-tests were used without correction.

Response: We have re-run the analyses using a Bonferroni correction. The primary result remains significant, and two secondary results are now reported as exploratory.

Change made: Methods, page 6, lines 18 to 22; Results, page 10; Table 3.

Comment 2.2: A six-month follow-up would strengthen the study.

Response: We agree that this would be valuable. The project has ended and ethical approval did not cover re-contact, so we have acknowledged this as a limitation and proposed a longitudinal design for future work.

Change made: Limitations, page 14, lines 10 to 16; Future Research, page 15.

Closing note

We hope the revised manuscript now meets the journal’s standards, and we are grateful to the editor and reviewers for helping us to improve it.

Yours sincerely, [Corresponding author, on behalf of all authors]

Adapting examples to your discipline

STEM and health research. Reviewers often ask for additional experiments, controls, statistical clarification, sample size justification and reporting-guideline compliance. Replies should be precise about numbers and methods, and should include new data in the letter when it is short.

Social sciences. Expect questions about theory, sampling, positionality, validity and generalisability. Use the Limitations section generously, and consider adding a sentence to show how you handled researcher bias or ethical considerations.

Humanities. Reviews tend to be more discursive, with comments about argument, framing, sources and engagement with critical debates. Your replies can be longer and more narrative, but each should still end with a specific location for the change.

PhD students. Share the draft with your supervisors, be careful with any claim about novelty, and use the process as practice for your viva. Cambridge University Libraries’ Demystifying Peer Review guide is a good primer if you are new to the system.

Table format versus narrative format

Some journals prefer a table. A simple three-column layout looks like this:

Reviewer commentAuthor responseLocation of change
1.1 The sample is not justified.We added a rationale and acknowledged the limitations.Methods 2.1, p. 5, lines 3-11
1.2 The research question is unclear.We restructured the Introduction.Introduction, pp. 2-3

Tables are compact and scannable but can feel cramped for long answers. Use a narrative layout (as in the sample letter) when your replies need more space. Whichever you choose, apply it to every comment.

Common mistakes the examples are designed to prevent

  • Vague replies such as “done” or “revised” with no location.
  • Silent disagreement, where you ignore a comment hoping nobody notices.
  • Defensive language that blames the reviewer for a misunderstanding.
  • Changes that are not in the manuscript, or text in the letter that does not match the final paper.
  • Over-long replies to small points, which bury the important ones.

For a fuller list and a pre-submission checklist, see our response to reviewers template. If the decision was major revisions, our guide on how to respond to major revisions and the tracked changes and clean copy post cover the next stages.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I find real examples of response to reviewers letters?

Some open-access journals publish peer review histories alongside articles, including reviewer reports and author responses. Check the article page for a “peer review history” or “reviewer reports” tab. Your supervisor, department or research office may also be willing to share anonymised examples from successful submissions.

How long should each reply be?

As long as it needs to be to answer fully, and no longer. A typographical fix may need one line. A methodological challenge may need a paragraph with evidence. Do not pad.

Can I copy these examples?

Use them as models for structure and tone, not as text to paste. Editors read many letters, and generic replies are easy to spot. Each reply must refer to your own data, your own changes and your own line numbers.

What if I only partly agree with a comment?

Say which part you agree with, make that change, explain why you did not adopt the rest, and show what you did instead. Example 7 shows this pattern.

How do I show new text in the letter?

Quote it in italics or a boxed paragraph and give the location. Keep quoted text short and refer to the tracked-changes file for longer passages.

Is it acceptable to say “we respectfully disagree”?

Yes, provided it is followed by evidence and by something you did to address the underlying concern. Used alone, it is unlikely to persuade anyone.

Further reading and trusted resources

Conclusion: use examples to learn the pattern, then write your own

Every strong reply in this guide follows the same pattern: acknowledge, act, explain, locate. Once you have that rhythm, even a long list of comments becomes manageable. Write your first draft quickly, check each reply against the manuscript, and keep your tone calm and professional.

If you would like an experienced editor to draft or polish your letter, Writers.ng can help. Start with our response to reviewers guide, or choose the support you need: