Revise and Resubmit vs Reject and Resubmit: What’s the Difference and What to Do Next

Qualitative vs Quantitative Dissertation: Which Should You Choose? | Writers.ng

The decision email has arrived, and it says neither “accept” nor “reject”. It says “revise and resubmit”, or perhaps “reject and resubmit”. You read the phrase three times. Is this good news? Bad news? Both?

Researchers across the UK and beyond ask this question every week, and the honest answer is: it depends. The two phrases look almost identical, they are used loosely by journals, and they can mean quite different things depending on the discipline, the publisher and the editor who wrote the letter. Misreading the decision can cost you months. Treat a “reject and resubmit” as a routine revision and you may submit a response that falls well short of what the editor expects. Treat a “revise and resubmit” as a polite rejection and you may walk away from a paper that was close to acceptance.

This guide explains exactly what each decision means, how they differ from “major revisions” and outright rejection, how to work out which one you have really been given, and how to plan your response. It sits within our wider series on responding to reviewers and builds on our guides to how to respond to major revisions and conflicting reviewer comments.

Table of Contents

If you would like an experienced editor to read your decision letter and give you a plan, our major revisions help service is designed for this moment.

Journal decisions in context: the full range of outcomes

To understand the two decisions in the title, it helps to see where they sit among all the possible outcomes. Most journals use some version of the following scale, from best to worst.

Accept. The paper is publishable as it stands. This is rare on first submission, though it does happen.

Accept with minor revisions. The paper is essentially ready, and the changes are small: wording, references, formatting, small clarifications. The editor often checks the changes personally.

Major revisions. The paper has potential but needs substantial work. The editor expects you to revise, and the revised version will usually go back to the original reviewers. The paper remains in the same manuscript record, and the journal expects a response within a set period.

Revise and resubmit (R&R). The editor invites you to revise the paper and submit it again, often with an understanding that the revision will be reviewed afresh. The exact meaning varies, as we explain below.

Reject and resubmit. The editor declines the current version but is willing to consider a substantially reworked version as a new submission. This is a closer call than a standard rejection, but it is not a promise.

Reject. The journal does not want the paper, and you are not invited to resubmit. You can send it elsewhere. See our guide to what to do after journal rejection.

Notice that “major revisions”, “revise and resubmit” and “reject and resubmit” form a spectrum of increasing distance from acceptance. The labels are not standardised, so you need to read the letter, not just the heading.

What “revise and resubmit” means

In its most common sense, “revise and resubmit” (often abbreviated to R&R) means that the editor thinks the paper could be publishable if the authors address the reviewers’ concerns satisfactorily. You are being invited to rework the manuscript and send it back.

In many journals, especially in the social sciences, humanities, economics, business and management, the R&R is the standard “positive but not yet” decision. It is roughly equivalent to major revisions in journals that use that term. The revised paper goes back to the editor and usually to the original reviewers, and the process may run for two or three rounds.

Typical features of a revise and resubmit decision include:

  • The editor writes that the paper “has merit” or “could make a contribution”.
  • The reviews raise significant but fixable concerns about theory, methods, analysis or framing.
  • The editor sets out what needs to change, sometimes in a numbered list.
  • There is a deadline for resubmission, though it can be generous (three to six months in some disciplines).
  • The revised paper keeps the same manuscript number or is linked to the original submission.
  • You are expected to submit a detailed response letter along with the revised manuscript.

An R&R is not an acceptance in disguise. Many R&Rs end in rejection if the revision does not satisfy the editor and the reviewers. But the odds are meaningfully better than for a fresh submission, because the editor has already decided the paper is worth pursuing.

What “reject and resubmit” means

Reject and resubmit (sometimes written “reject with encouragement to resubmit”) is a different and more cautious decision. The editor is formally rejecting the current version of the paper but leaving the door open to a substantially revised version.

Features of a reject and resubmit decision often include:

  • The editor writes that the current manuscript is “not suitable in its present form” but that a “substantially revised” version could be considered.
  • The concerns raised are fundamental: a weak research design, a thin contribution, a poorly specified model, a mismatch with the journal’s scope, a need for new data or a reframed argument.
  • There may be no guarantee that a resubmission will be reviewed, or that it will go back to the same reviewers.
  • The resubmission may be handled as a new manuscript with a new number, and may be subject to a fresh round of triage.
  • The deadline may be flexible, because significant new work may be needed.
  • The editor may say explicitly that resubmission is not guaranteed to lead to acceptance.

The word “reject” matters. In many systems, a reject and resubmit decision is recorded as a rejection, which closes the original submission. If you return with a new version, it is technically a new submission, though it may be linked to the earlier one.

The key differences at a glance

Because the terminology varies, think in terms of features rather than labels. These are the differences that usually matter.

The editor’s level of commitment. With a revise and resubmit, the editor is signalling a genuine intention to continue. With reject and resubmit, the editor is saying “this is not there yet, and I am not promising anything”.

The scale of the work. R&R revisions are usually substantial but achievable within the existing study. Reject and resubmit often requires deeper changes: new data, new analysis, a rebuilt theoretical framework or a rewritten paper.

The status of your manuscript. An R&R keeps the paper in the system. A reject and resubmit usually closes the original record and requires a new submission.

The route back through peer review. An R&R generally goes back to the same reviewers. A reject and resubmit may go to new reviewers, or be screened again by the editor.

The timeline. R&R deadlines are usually fixed. Reject and resubmit timelines are more open-ended, though the editor may have a preferred window.

The likelihood of eventual acceptance. No journal publishes reliable figures, and they vary hugely by field and title. Broadly, R&R carries better odds than reject and resubmit, but both depend on the quality of your response.

If you are unsure which category your decision falls into, treat the letter as a message to decode, not a label to accept.

How to tell which one you really have

Journals do not always use these terms consistently, so you need to read between the lines. Work through the following questions.

What does the decision letter actually say?

Look at the exact words. “We invite you to revise your manuscript and resubmit” points towards R&R. “We are unable to accept your manuscript in its current form but would be willing to consider a substantially revised version” points towards reject and resubmit.

How is the decision recorded in the submission system?

Log in to the manuscript portal. If the status says “Revision requested” or “Major revision”, you are in the R&R or major revisions track. If it says “Rejected” or “Decision: reject”, you probably have a reject and resubmit.

Does the editor commit to sending it back to the reviewers?

If yes, you are likely in R&R territory. If the letter says “we cannot guarantee that a revised version will be sent for review”, it is closer to reject and resubmit.

What kind of changes are requested?

Smaller fixes and clarifications suggest R&R or major revisions. A request to reconceptualise the paper, collect new data or change the research question suggests reject and resubmit.

What does your field expect?

In economics, political science, sociology and management, “revise and resubmit” is a prestigious, widely used outcome, and many strong papers publish after one or two R&Rs. In many natural science and medical journals, “major revisions” is the standard term and “revise and resubmit” is less common. In the humanities, editors may use the term informally for almost any invitation to revise.

Can you simply ask?

Yes. If the letter is ambiguous, write a short, polite email to the editor. For example:

Dear Dr [Surname],

Thank you for your decision on manuscript [number]. We are grateful for the reviewers’ detailed comments and are keen to revise. To make sure we respond appropriately, could you confirm whether the revised manuscript will be treated as a continuation of the current submission and sent back to the original reviewers, or considered as a new submission?

With thanks, [Name]

Editors generally appreciate the clarity, and the answer will shape your plan.

What both decisions have in common

Despite their differences, the two decisions share a crucial feature: the editor sees potential in the paper. A journal that wants nothing to do with your work simply rejects it. By inviting a resubmission, the editor is saying that something in the paper is worth the effort, whether it is the topic, the data, the argument or the contribution.

That matters for how you respond. In both cases, you need to:

  • Understand exactly what the editor and reviewers want.
  • Distinguish essential concerns from optional ones.
  • Respond to every comment, courteously and specifically.
  • Show that you have strengthened the paper in substance, not only in wording.
  • Present your changes clearly, with a well-structured response letter and a tracked-changes manuscript.

The main difference lies in how much work is required and how much risk you carry.

How to respond to a revise and resubmit decision

If you have received an R&R, you are in the same position as an author with major revisions. The process is described in detail in our step-by-step guide to major revisions, but the essentials are these.

Read the editor’s letter first. Identify the concerns the editor marks as essential. These are your priorities.

Break the reports into individual comments. Number them, categorise them and build a response matrix that tracks each one.

Decide what to accept, partly accept or rebut. You must engage with every point, but you do not have to agree with every point. Where you disagree, use evidence and a courteous tone. See how to disagree with a reviewer politely.

Handle conflicts deliberately. If reviewers contradict one another, follow the editor’s guidance where it exists and explain your reasoning. See conflicting reviewer comments.

Revise the manuscript thoroughly. Update every section affected by your changes. Check that the abstract, results, discussion and conclusions remain consistent.

Prepare a tracked-changes copy and a clean copy. See our guide on tracked changes and clean copy.

Write a clear, structured response letter. Our response to reviewers template and examples show how.

Respect the deadline. If you need more time, ask early. See how long you have to resubmit after revisions.

Because R&R submissions are typically sent back to the same reviewers, your response letter is read by people who know exactly what they asked for. Be precise about what you changed and where.

How to respond to a reject and resubmit decision

A reject and resubmit decision requires a more strategic approach, because the stakes and the uncertainty are higher. Follow these steps.

Step back and decide whether to continue

Before you invest weeks in revising, ask yourself whether this journal is the right home. Consider:

  • Are the editor’s concerns fixable within your study, or do they point to a fundamental mismatch?
  • Do you believe in the changes being requested, or would you be bending the paper into something you no longer recognise?
  • How long would the revision take, and can you afford that time given your thesis, your funding or your career stage?
  • Are there other journals that might be a better fit, with a less demanding process?

If the revision is feasible and the journal is a strong fit, resubmitting can be worthwhile. If not, it may be wiser to take the feedback and send a stronger paper elsewhere, as explained in our guide on what to do after journal rejection.

Clarify the process with the editor

Reject and resubmit has no universal rules, so ask about the practicalities:

  • Will the revised paper be handled by the same editor?
  • Will it go back to the same reviewers, new reviewers or both?
  • Is there a deadline for resubmission?
  • Will it be assigned a new manuscript number?
  • Is there anything else you should include, such as a cover letter or response document?

A short email, as in the example earlier, is enough.

Identify the fundamental concerns

Reject and resubmit decisions usually turn on two or three core problems. Read the editor’s letter and the reviews to find them. Typical examples include:

  • A research question that is too narrow, too broad or insufficiently justified.
  • A theoretical contribution that is not clearly distinguished from existing work.
  • A methodological weakness, such as inadequate sampling, weak identification, an inappropriate model or insufficient data.
  • A discussion that overstates the findings.
  • A mismatch with the journal’s scope or audience.

Concentrate on these. Fixing a hundred minor issues will not rescue a paper whose central weakness remains.

Plan the substantive work

Be realistic about what is needed. You may have to collect additional data, rerun the analysis with a different approach, rebuild the literature review, rewrite the introduction or restructure the argument. Draw up a plan with milestones and deadlines, agree responsibilities with your co-authors and build in time for internal review.

Write a response document that makes the case

Even when the resubmission is technically a new submission, you should still include a response document that explains how you addressed the concerns. Many editors expect it, and it makes their task easier. Structure it as you would for a standard response, with each comment followed by your response and the location of the change.

Include a short summary at the start of the major changes, since the editor may not remember the details of the original submission.

Explain the changes in your cover letter

Your cover letter should say, in plain terms, that this is a resubmission following a “reject and resubmit” decision, refer to the earlier manuscript number, summarise the main changes and thank the editor for the opportunity. Keep it brief and professional.

Be honest about what you could not do

If there are requests you could not meet, say so, explain why and show what you did instead. Editors respect honesty, and a transparent limitation is less damaging than an unexplained omission.

Submit a paper that stands on its own

Because the revised paper may be assessed by a new reviewer who has not seen the original, it should read as a coherent, polished piece in its own right. Do not rely on the response letter to explain what the paper itself does not make clear.

Should you resubmit to the same journal?

This is the question that troubles many researchers after a reject and resubmit, and it deserves a careful answer.

Reasons to resubmit:

  • The editor has invested time and shown interest in the paper.
  • The reviewers’ feedback is constructive, and you can address it.
  • The journal is a good fit for your topic and audience.
  • The journal’s standing matters for your career, your thesis or institutional goals such as the Research Excellence Framework.
  • The revision will improve the paper regardless of where it is published.

Reasons to think twice:

  • The required changes would alter the paper in ways you do not agree with.
  • The timeline is too long for your circumstances.
  • The editor’s language is lukewarm, and the chances appear slim.
  • You have identified a better-suited journal.
  • Waiting for a new round of review would delay a thesis submission or an application.

There is no shame in moving on. Whichever route you choose, the feedback you have received is valuable. Use it to improve the paper before it goes anywhere.

Do not confuse “resubmit” with “submit elsewhere”

An important point: a reject and resubmit decision invites you to return to this journal. It is not permission to submit the same manuscript to another journal at the same time. Never submit a paper to two journals simultaneously. Most journals prohibit it, and the guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) treats duplicate submission as a serious integrity concern.

If you choose to move to another journal, formally withdraw or confirm the rejection with the first one, and revise the paper before sending it on. Take the reviewers’ feedback seriously, because a future reviewer may raise the same points.

How the terms vary by discipline

Publishing cultures differ, and the same phrase can mean different things.

Economics, business and management. R&R is the norm. Authors often go through two or three R&R rounds, and a first-round R&R is widely regarded as a strong outcome. Reject and resubmit is less common but exists.

Political science, sociology and the wider social sciences. R&R is widely used. Journals often explain in the letter how strong the invitation is.

Humanities. Terms vary and are used loosely. Many humanities journals have fewer formal categories, and editors may write more personal, discursive letters. Read for intent.

Natural sciences, engineering and medicine. “Major revisions” and “minor revisions” are more common than R&R. Where “reject and resubmit” appears, it often means the journal wants substantial new work before reconsidering.

Interdisciplinary and applied fields. Practices are mixed. Check the journal’s author guidelines and recent editorials for clues.

If you are working across disciplines, do not assume that your field’s convention applies. Read the journal’s own instructions and, if necessary, ask the editor.

A realistic timeline for each decision

Plan your time differently for each outcome.

Revise and resubmit. Typical journal deadlines range from one to six months, depending on the field. Work back from the deadline: allow a week for analysis of the reports, two to six weeks for the revision itself, a week for the response letter and a week for final checks and submission. If you need more time, ask early.

Reject and resubmit. Allow longer. If you need new data or a major rewrite, the work may take several months. Agree a timeline with the editor and keep them informed if it changes.

Alternative route. If you decide to submit elsewhere, allow a few weeks to revise the paper, reformat for the new journal and write a fresh cover letter.

UK researchers should also consider the academic calendar. Teaching blocks, marking periods, vivas and holidays can all squeeze the available time, and funder or institutional deadlines may add pressure. Editors tend to be sympathetic to a polite request for an extension made early.

Writing the response: tone and language

Whichever decision you have, the tone of your response matters. British academic writing tends to favour measured, formal and courteous phrasing, and this suits both the response letter and the cover note.

Be grateful, but not gushing. Thank the editor and reviewers once, sincerely, then get to the substance.

Be specific. Say what you changed, where, and why.

Be respectful when you disagree. “We respectfully take a different view” is stronger than “The reviewer is mistaken”.

Be honest. If you could not do something, say so and explain.

Use British spelling consistently. Set your word processor to English (UK) and check that your reference list follows the same convention.

The University of Manchester’s Academic Phrasebank offers model phrases for acknowledging limitations, introducing contrasting views and presenting reasoned changes, and is a useful free reference when you are drafting.

Common mistakes to avoid

Misreading the decision. Treating a reject and resubmit as a minor revision, or an R&R as a rejection, leads to the wrong response.

Not asking the editor. Where the letter is unclear, a short query saves time.

Rushing. A hurried response that ignores key concerns is likely to end in rejection, even after an encouraging first decision.

Resubmitting without a response document. Even when not strictly required, a clear response letter is expected in almost all cases.

Changing only the wording. Cosmetic edits do not address substantive concerns. Reviewers will notice if the real problems remain.

Defensiveness. Treating the reviews as an attack undermines your response.

Submitting elsewhere at the same time. This is a breach of publication ethics.

Ignoring the editor’s priorities. The editor’s letter tells you which points matter most.

Missing the deadline. If you cannot meet it, ask for an extension before it passes.

Failing to proofread. Errors in the response letter or revised manuscript suggest carelessness.

Resources that can help

The following freely available resources are useful when you are interpreting a decision, planning a revision or choosing where to go next. None are commercial writing services.

  • COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) offers guidance on peer review, resubmission, duplicate submission and authorship.
  • ICMJE Recommendations set out widely followed standards for authorship, disclosure and manuscript preparation.
  • EQUATOR Network collects reporting guidelines that can help you strengthen your methods and reporting in a revised manuscript.
  • Academic Phrasebank (University of Manchester) offers help with academic phrasing.
  • Think. Check. Submit. helps you assess whether a journal is trustworthy if you are considering moving your paper.
  • Sherpa Romeo summarises journal open access and self-archiving policies.
  • UKRI and Jisc provide information on UK funder expectations and open access agreements, which may influence your choice of journal.
  • Vitae supports researcher development in the UK, with material on publishing and career planning.
  • ORCID provides a persistent researcher identifier that many journals request at submission and revision.

When to get professional support

Interpreting a decision and planning a response can be easier with a second pair of eyes. Consider support if:

  • The decision letter is ambiguous and you are not sure what is expected.
  • The reviews are long, technical or contradictory.
  • The revision involves substantial restructuring or new analysis.
  • You are working under time pressure, perhaps alongside teaching, fieldwork or a thesis deadline.
  • English is not your first language and you want your response to read naturally to UK-based editors.
  • The paper is important for a promotion case, a funding application or a doctoral programme.

At Writers.ng, our editors help researchers read decision letters, analyse reviewer comments, plan revisions and write clear, courteous response letters. See our reviewer comments analysis, rebuttal letter help, response letter writing service and manuscript revision and editing pages for details. You remain the author and the decision-maker. We help you present your work as clearly as possible, within the journal’s policies on assistance.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between revise and resubmit and reject and resubmit?

A revise and resubmit invites you to rework the paper and return it, usually as a continuation of the same submission and often to the same reviewers. A reject and resubmit formally declines the current version but is willing to consider a substantially reworked one, often as a new submission, with no guarantee of review or acceptance.

Is revise and resubmit a good sign?

Yes. It means the editor sees real potential in your paper. It is not a guarantee of acceptance, but it is a strong signal, particularly in the social sciences, economics and management.

Is reject and resubmit a rejection?

Technically yes, because the current version has been declined. In practice it is an encouraging form of rejection that leaves the door open. How wide the door is depends on the editor’s wording.

Is revise and resubmit the same as major revisions?

In many journals they are close to equivalent. Some journals use “major revisions” for science and medicine, and “revise and resubmit” for social science and humanities. Others use both, with R&R implying a more substantial reworking. Read the letter for detail.

Will my revised paper go back to the same reviewers?

Usually, with an R&R, yes. With a reject and resubmit, it may go to the same reviewers, new reviewers or be screened by the editor first. Ask the editor if the letter is unclear.

How long do I have to resubmit?

It varies. Many journals give one to three months for major revisions, and some R&R processes allow up to six months or more. For reject and resubmit, the timeline may be flexible. Check the letter and ask for an extension early if needed. See how long to resubmit after revisions.

Do I need to write a response letter for a reject and resubmit?

Yes, in almost all cases. Even if it is not strictly required, a clear response document helps the editor and any reviewer see how you have addressed the concerns.

Can I submit the paper to another journal instead?

Yes, if you decide not to resubmit. But do not submit to another journal while the paper is still under consideration at the first. Duplicate submission is an integrity breach. Improve the paper using the feedback before you send it elsewhere.

What are my chances of acceptance after a revise and resubmit?

There are no reliable universal figures. In general, your chances are meaningfully better than for a new submission, but they depend on the strength of your response and the nature of the concerns. A careful, complete and courteous revision gives you the best chance.

What if I disagree with the reviewers?

You may disagree, provided you give reasons and evidence and remain courteous. See our guide to disagreeing with a reviewer politely.

What if the reviewers contradict each other?

Follow the editor’s guidance where it exists, look for a solution that addresses both concerns and explain your decision in both responses. See conflicting reviewer comments.

Should I use tracked changes?

Almost always, alongside a clean copy. Check the journal’s instructions. See tracked changes and clean copy.

Can a professional editor help me?

Yes. Professional editors can help you interpret the decision, plan the revision, structure the response and polish the language, while you make the scientific decisions and remain responsible for the content. Always follow the journal’s policies on assistance and the guidance from COPE.

Key takeaways

  • Revise and resubmit and reject and resubmit are not the same, though journals use them loosely.
  • R&R is an invitation to continue; reject and resubmit is a formal rejection with an open door.
  • Read the letter, check the submission system and, if in doubt, ask the editor.
  • Both decisions mean the editor sees potential, so respond with care.
  • For R&R, follow the major revisions process and respond to every comment.
  • For reject and resubmit, decide first whether to continue, then clarify the process and focus on the fundamental concerns.
  • Never submit the same paper to another journal while it is still under consideration.
  • Keep your tone courteous and specific, and use British spelling for UK-facing journals.
  • Allow realistic time, and ask for an extension early if needed.
  • Get professional support when the decision, the deadline or the stakes make it worthwhile.

Need help interpreting your decision?

If you are looking at a decision letter and are not sure whether you have an R&R, a reject and resubmit or something in between, the Writers.ng team can help. We read the letter, analyse the reviews, recommend a plan and support you through the response.

Visit our response to reviewers service or contact us through our major revisions help page to get started.