You have received the decision letter. The editor has asked you to revise your paper, and the instructions say something like: “Please upload a revised manuscript with tracked changes, a clean copy, and a point-by-point response to reviewers.” If you have never done this before, that single sentence can feel like three separate jobs. It is not. It is one revision, presented in three ways, and each version has a different reader and a different purpose.
This guide explains exactly what a tracked changes file and a clean copy are, why UK and international journals ask for both, how to produce them correctly in Microsoft Word, and which mistakes cause avoidable delays at the editorial office. It is written for researchers submitting to UK-based journals and publishers, to journals that follow UK conventions, and to any author at a UK university or research institute who wants a smooth resubmission.
It is part of our wider series on responding to peer review. If you are still at the stage of deciding how to answer the reviewers themselves, start with our main guide to responding to reviewers and come back here when you are ready to build the files.
Table of Contents
- What are tracked changes and a clean copy?
- Why journals ask for both versions
- The full resubmission package at a glance
- How to prepare the tracked changes version in Word
- How to create the clean copy
- Tracked changes vs highlighting vs clean copy
- Linking your files to the response letter
- Ten common mistakes (and how to avoid them)
- Working with co-authors and supervisors
- Special cases: Mac, Word online, Google Docs and LaTeX
- UK-specific points: open access, funders and thesis corrections
- Final pre-upload checklist
- When to ask for professional help
- Frequently asked questions
- Useful external resources
1. What are tracked changes and a clean copy?
The tracked changes version
A tracked changes manuscript is your revised paper with every edit visible. In Microsoft Word, the Track Changes feature records each insertion, deletion, move and formatting change, and attributes it to the person who made it. Insertions typically appear underlined in colour, deletions appear struck through, and a vertical bar in the margin marks each altered line.
Journals use different names for this file. You may see it called:
- the marked-up manuscript
- the revised manuscript with changes tracked
- the redlined version
- the manuscript with changes highlighted
- “Revised manuscript – tracked changes” in the submission system’s file-type menu
The key idea is the same in every case: the editor and reviewers must be able to see, without comparing two documents by eye, exactly what you altered since the previous version.
The clean copy
The clean copy is the same revised manuscript with all markup removed. There are no coloured underlines, no struck-through text, no comment bubbles and no highlighting. It reads exactly as the paper would appear if it were accepted today.
The clean copy is the version that, if the editor accepts your paper, moves forward into copy-editing and typesetting. For that reason, any residue of markup in it is a problem, and we will cover how to avoid that in section 5.
A simple way to remember the difference
| Tracked changes version | Clean copy | |
|---|---|---|
| Shows | Every edit since the last version | The finished text only |
| Main reader | Reviewers and the handling editor | Editor, then production team |
| Purpose | Verify what changed | Read the paper naturally; use as the accepted text |
| Markup visible | Yes | No |
| Comments in margin | Usually none, unless the journal asks | None |
Both files must contain identical wording. The only difference is whether the edits are shown.
2. Why journals ask for both versions
Editors are busy and reviewers are unpaid. When a revised manuscript comes back, the reviewer is not reading it with fresh eyes; they are checking whether you did what you said you would do. Giving them a tracked changes file saves hours of hunting for differences.
There are four practical reasons journals ask for both files.
1. Verification. The tracked changes version lets a reviewer open the paper, jump from edit to edit, and cross-check each one against your response. If your response letter says “we have added a paragraph on sampling limitations in the Discussion”, the reviewer should be able to find that paragraph in seconds.
2. Readability. A heavily marked-up paper can be tiring to read. The clean copy allows the editor to judge the paper as a coherent piece of writing rather than as a patchwork of edits.
3. Production. If the paper is accepted, the clean version is the starting point for copy-editing. Hidden tracked changes, stray comments or leftover highlighting can slow production or, worse, end up in the typeset proof.
4. Audit trail. Some journals, particularly those following the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), want a transparent record of how the manuscript developed through peer review. A clear marked-up version supports that transparency.
The three documents also work as a system. The response letter tells the story, the tracked changes file proves it, and the clean copy delivers the result. If any one of them contradicts another, reviewers notice quickly. We look at the response letter itself in our guides to the response letter writing service and to rebuttal letter help.
3. The full resubmission package at a glance
Most journals ask for some or all of the following. Always read the specific instructions in your decision letter and the journal’s author guidelines, because requirements differ.
| File | What it is | Typically required? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Response to reviewers | Point-by-point reply to every comment | Almost always | Addressed to the editor; thanks reviewers |
| Revised manuscript with tracked changes | Marked-up version | Very often | Sometimes called “marked copy” |
| Clean revised manuscript | Markup-free version | Very often | Must match tracked version word for word |
| Cover letter | Short covering note | Sometimes | Some systems merge it with the response letter |
| Updated figures and tables | Replacement or new files | If changed | Use the journal’s file naming rules |
| Supplementary files | Appendices, datasets, code | If changed | Keep file names consistent |
| Anonymised files | Blinded manuscript and title page | For double-anonymous review | Remove author details from the file itself, not just the text |
| Declarations | Funding, conflicts, ethics, data availability | If changed | Update if anything has changed since first submission |
A few journals ask for a single combined file containing the response letter followed by the tracked changes manuscript. Others want everything uploaded separately. The submission system will usually tell you which file types it expects in a drop-down menu when you upload.
If your decision was major revisions and you are still working out how to structure a reply to many comments, see our practical guide to major revisions help, and our article on how to respond to major revisions.
4. How to prepare the tracked changes version in Word
The most reliable method is to turn on Track Changes before you start revising, and leave it on until the revision is finished. That way Word records everything as you work. These instructions apply to current versions of Microsoft Word for Windows and are very similar on Mac.
Step 1: Save the original version safely
Before you touch anything, save a copy of the manuscript exactly as you submitted it. Use a clear file name such as:
Smith_2026_Manuscript_v1_submitted.docx
This is your reference point. If something goes wrong later, you can always go back or run a comparison against it.
Step 2: Make a working copy
Save a second copy for the revision:
Smith_2026_Manuscript_v2_tracked.docx
Work only in this file. Do not edit the original.
Step 3: Turn on Track Changes
Go to the Review tab and select Track Changes. Word now records edits in the document. You should see the button highlighted. According to Microsoft’s guidance on tracking changes, the markup is visible to anyone who views the document in All Markup or Simple Markup mode, so it is worth switching between views to check how the file will appear to a reviewer.
Step 4: Check the author name
Word attributes each change to the name stored in your Office settings. If you are submitting a double-anonymous paper, that name could reveal your identity. Before you begin, check File > Options > General and review the user name, or use a neutral label such as “Author” if the journal requires anonymity. We return to this in section 8.
Step 5: Revise systematically
Work through the reviewer comments in order. For each one:
- Read the comment carefully.
- Decide on the response: change the text, add new analysis, clarify, or politely decline with a reason.
- Make the edit in the manuscript with Track Changes on.
- Immediately note the location in your response letter (page and line number, or section heading).
Doing the response letter and the manuscript edits side by side prevents the most common problem of all: a response that promises a change that is not actually in the paper.
Step 6: Let Word do the recording; do not format by hand
Resist the urge to mark changes manually by turning text red or adding your own strike-through. Manual formatting is not tracked, it is easy to forget to remove, and it cannot be accepted or rejected cleanly. Always use the Track Changes feature. If the journal asks for changes “highlighted in yellow” instead, see section 6.
Step 7: Handle moved text carefully
When you move a paragraph from one section to another, Word may record it as a deletion in one place and an insertion in another, or as a tracked move. Both are fine, but they can confuse reviewers. Where a large block has been moved, add a short note in your response letter explaining that the text has been relocated rather than rewritten. A line such as “The paragraph on measurement validity has been moved from the Methods to the Limitations section; the wording is unchanged” saves a reviewer from wondering whether content was added or lost.
Step 8: Keep tables and figures in view
Tracked changes inside tables can be awkward to read, especially in wide tables. If you have changed numbers in a table, mention the specific table and row in your response letter. If you have replaced a figure, say so explicitly, because image swaps are not always displayed clearly as tracked changes.
Step 9: Review the markup before saving it as final
Switch the view to All Markup and scroll through the whole document. Look for:
- accidental changes you did not intend
- formatting changes cluttering the file (for example, changes to every heading style)
- stray punctuation or spacing alterations that came from copy-pasting
- comments you meant to delete
If the markup is full of trivial formatting noise, consider whether you can reduce it by applying styles consistently before turning tracking on.
What if you forgot to turn on Track Changes?
This happens often. You finish the revision and realise you edited with tracking off. You have a fix: Word’s Compare feature.
- Open the Review tab and choose Compare > Compare.
- Select your original submitted version as the “Original document”.
- Select your revised, untracked version as the “Revised document”.
- Word generates a third document showing all differences as tracked changes.
Check the result carefully. Compare sometimes produces cluttered markup around tables, citations managed by reference software and special formatting, so treat it as a rescue method rather than your first choice.
5. How to create the clean copy
The clean copy must be properly clean. That means more than just “it looks fine on screen”. Hidden markup, comments and metadata can survive in a file that appears tidy.
Step 1: Start from the tracked version
Never create the clean copy from scratch or by retyping. Always generate it from the finished tracked changes file, so the wording is guaranteed to match.
Step 2: Save a separate file first
Before you accept any changes, use Save As and name the new file clearly:
Smith_2026_Manuscript_v2_clean.docx
This protects your tracked version from being altered accidentally.
Step 3: Accept all changes
In the clean file, go to Review > Accept > Accept All Changes. According to Microsoft’s support page on accepting or rejecting tracked changes, you must use the Accept and Reject commands to remove markup from the document; switching the view to hide it is not enough. Note too that the document may still contain markup even if Track Changes is currently switched off, because earlier edits remain visible until they are accepted or rejected.
There is a subtle trap here. If you have used the “Show Markup” filter to hide certain reviewers or types of change, the command Accept All Changes Shown will accept only what is currently displayed. Choose Accept All Changes to be sure everything is dealt with, or set the display to show all reviewers first.
Step 4: Turn off Track Changes
After accepting everything, make sure the Track Changes button is switched off in the clean file. Otherwise, any final tidy-ups will be recorded as new markup.
Step 5: Delete all comments
Comments are not tracked changes, so accepting all changes does not remove them. In the Review tab, use Delete > Delete All Comments in Document. Pay special attention to comments you left for yourself or for co-authors during drafting. These are the comments most likely to cause embarrassment if they reach the editor.
Step 6: Remove highlighting
If you highlighted text in yellow for your own use, remove it in the clean copy. Select the whole document and set the highlight colour to “No Colour”. Check that you have not removed intentional formatting at the same time.
Step 7: Inspect the document for hidden data
Word has a built-in Document Inspector that can find comments, revisions, hidden text and personal information. Run it on a copy of your clean file, because some removals cannot be undone. Microsoft’s guidance on removing hidden data and personal information explains what each inspection category covers. In practice:
- Choose File > Info > Check for Issues > Inspect Document.
- Tick the categories you want to check and select Inspect.
- Review the results and select Remove All beside the categories you want cleared.
This step matters most for double-anonymous review, where author names in document properties can undermine the anonymity of the process.
Step 8: Update fields and cross-references
Right-click and update fields, or press Ctrl + A then F9 in Windows, so that table of contents entries, figure numbers and cross-references are correct. Then check page numbers and line numbers if the journal requires them.
Step 9: Proofread the clean copy once more
Read the clean file from start to finish as if you were a reviewer seeing it for the first time. Check that sentences flow, that no half-deleted phrases remain, and that new text blends with the old. Accepting changes sometimes exposes grammatical joins that looked fine in markup.
Step 10: Compare the clean copy against the tracked version
If you want absolute certainty, accept all changes in a temporary copy of the tracked file and compare it with your clean copy using Word’s Compare tool. If the comparison shows no differences, the files match. This is a quick final safeguard and takes less than two minutes.
6. Tracked changes vs highlighting vs clean copy
Journals do not all ask for the same kind of marked-up file. Some prefer tracked changes, others still ask for highlighting, and a few accept either. The table below compares the options.
| Method | How it looks | Advantages | Disadvantages | Best used when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Track Changes | Coloured insertions, struck-through deletions, margin bars | Shows deletions as well as additions; attributable; reversible | Can look cluttered after major rewriting | The journal asks for “tracked changes” or “marked-up manuscript” |
| Highlighting | Changed text shaded in yellow or another colour | Simple to read; shows only the new text | Does not show what was deleted; manual and error-prone | The journal specifically asks for highlighted changes |
| Clean copy | No markup | Reads naturally; ready for production | Does not show what changed | Always supplied alongside a marked version |
| Compare document | Automatically generated differences | Rescues a revision made without tracking | Can be messy with tables and reference software | You forgot to track changes |
| Response letter quotation | Quoted new text inside the letter | Reviewers can see the change without opening the paper | Lengthens the letter | The journal asks for revised text to be quoted in the reply |
If you are unsure which the journal wants, check the author guidelines first and the wording of the decision email second. If the instructions are still ambiguous, you can send a one-line query to the editorial office. It is far better to ask than to upload the wrong file type and have the submission returned.
A useful rule: supply what the journal asks for, and nothing that contradicts it. A journal that wants yellow highlighting does not want a tracked changes file instead, however thorough that file is.
7. Linking your files to the response letter
The three documents should work together. A reviewer reading your response letter should be able to move straight to the relevant place in the manuscript.
Use page and line numbers
If the journal uses line numbering, add it to both manuscript versions (Layout > Line Numbers > Continuous) so that the same text sits on the same line in each. Then cite the location in the response letter in a consistent format, for example “Page 7, lines 142–155”.
A caution: line numbers differ between the tracked and clean versions if insertions and deletions change the layout. Decide which version your response letter refers to, and say so in the first paragraph. Most journals expect the response to reference the revised text, which usually means the clean copy’s numbering. State this clearly: “Line numbers in this letter refer to the clean revised manuscript.”
Quote key changes in the letter
For substantive changes, copy the new text into the response letter and set it apart, for instance in italics or an indented block. This lets reviewers judge the change instantly. For minor edits, a location reference is enough.
Keep the numbering of comments consistent
Number reviewer comments exactly as they appear in the decision letter (Reviewer 1, Comment 1.1; Reviewer 2, Comment 2.3, and so on). Use the same numbering in any internal notes, so you can trace each comment to its edit.
Never claim a change you did not make
If the letter says a limitation paragraph was added, the paragraph must exist in both versions of the paper. Mismatches between letter and manuscript are among the quickest ways to lose a reviewer’s confidence. Our guide to reviewer comments analysis shows how to build a comment tracker that prevents this.
Disagreeing politely and still showing your work
If you decide not to make a requested change, explain why in the letter, support the explanation with evidence, and consider whether a small clarification in the paper can address the underlying concern. Even a declined suggestion often benefits from a short, tracked addition that shows you took it seriously. For wording and tone, see how to disagree with a reviewer politely. Where reviewers contradict each other, read conflicting reviewer comments.
8. Ten common mistakes (and how to avoid them)
1. Submitting only one version
If the journal asks for both a tracked changes file and a clean copy, uploading only one can delay the paper at the technical check stage. Read the instructions twice.
2. Leaving Track Changes switched on in the clean copy
The clean file looks fine, but the next small edit appears as new markup. Always switch tracking off after accepting all changes.
3. Forgetting to delete comments
Internal comments such as “check this with Prof. Jones” or “do we really believe this number?” are a classic embarrassment. Delete them all in the clean copy, and delete or resolve them in the tracked copy unless the journal asks for explanatory comments.
4. Hidden metadata that breaks anonymity
For double-anonymous review, check document properties, tracked change author names, comment author names and headers or footers. Run the Document Inspector on the final files.
5. Mismatched wording between the two files
If you make a last-minute correction in the clean copy and forget to make it in the tracked version, the two documents no longer match. Always make edits in the tracked version first, then regenerate the clean copy.
6. A messy tracked file full of formatting noise
If every heading, table and reference is flagged as changed because of a style adjustment, the genuine edits are buried. Apply formatting changes before you begin tracking, or confine them to the clean version only where the journal allows.
7. Response letter line numbers that do not match
Check that the line numbers cited in your letter correspond to the version you say they refer to. Open the file and spot-check at least five citations.
8. Unupdated references and citations
After inserting new references, update your reference manager and check that the numbering or author–date citations are correct in both files. Field codes from reference software can behave unpredictably when changes are accepted, so check the bibliography carefully.
9. Ignoring figure and table updates
New or revised figures must be uploaded as separate files in the format the journal specifies. Do not assume that an embedded replacement in the Word file is enough. State in the response letter which figure files have changed.
10. Missing the deadline
Most journals give authors a fixed window, commonly several weeks, to resubmit, though this varies and extensions are often possible if you ask early. If you are running out of time, write to the editor before the deadline rather than after it. For more on timing, read our article on how long to resubmit after revisions.
9. Working with co-authors and supervisors
Revising a paper rarely happens alone. Co-authors, supervisors and collaborators may all edit the document, and uncoordinated editing is the main reason tracked changes files become unmanageable.
Agree on one master file
Nominate one person as the keeper of the master document. Everyone else sends comments or suggested edits that the keeper integrates. If several people edit different copies, merging them later is slow and error-prone.
Use distinct author names
When several people track changes in the same file, Word colours each author differently. This helps you see who suggested what, but remember to reduce the markup to the revision since the last submission, not the entire drafting history. If the file contains old tracked changes from the earlier draft, accept them in a baseline copy before starting the revision round.
Set an internal deadline
Allow time for co-authors to approve the final text. A sensible pattern is to circulate the response letter and tracked manuscript for comment, collect feedback by a fixed date, and then finalise both files together. Everyone listed as an author should have seen and approved the final version before it is uploaded, a principle reflected in widely used authorship standards such as the ICMJE recommendations.
Keep a version log
A simple table recording version number, date, who edited and what changed will save confusion. Even a plain text note at the top of a shared folder is better than nothing.
Supervisors and student authors
If you are a doctoral researcher, your supervisor will often want to read both versions. Provide the tracked version for detail and the clean version for flow. Give them realistic time to respond, because a rushed review is likely to miss exactly the sort of mismatch that causes problems later.
10. Special cases: Mac, Word online, Google Docs and LaTeX
Word for Mac
The Track Changes feature works in the same way on Mac, and the Review tab layout is almost identical. The Document Inspector is available under the Tools or File menus depending on your version. Check the menu names in your own installation, since Microsoft has changed them over time.
Word for the web
Word online supports tracked changes, but some advanced features, such as certain Compare options and the full Document Inspector, may be limited. If you need those, open the file in the desktop application.
Google Docs
Google Docs uses “Suggesting” mode rather than Track Changes. If you drafted in Google Docs, the safest approach is to download the revised version as a Word file, then check carefully how suggestions have converted. Some formatting and comment behaviour changes during conversion. If the journal wants a Word file with tracked changes, test the converted file by opening it in desktop Word and running the Review tab checks described above.
LaTeX
If you write in LaTeX, a marked-up PDF is usually generated with a difference tool such as latexdiff, which produces a version with additions and deletions coloured. Many journals that accept LaTeX also accept a diff PDF as the “tracked changes” file. Check the journal’s guidance on whether it wants the source files, a PDF, or both. Your clean copy in this case is simply the compiled final PDF plus the source files, if requested.
PDF markup
Some authors try to supply a PDF with highlighted edits instead of a Word file. Only do this if the journal explicitly allows it. Most editorial systems prefer editable source files for the clean copy and a readable marked-up file for reviewers.
Reference management software
Citation fields created by Zotero, EndNote and Mendeley may behave oddly with tracked changes. A practical approach is to finish text edits first with tracking on, update the citations, and check the bibliography in both versions. Avoid unlinking fields unless you are certain the journal’s production process requires plain text.
11. UK-specific points: open access, funders and thesis corrections
Because this guide is written for researchers in and around the United Kingdom, three UK-specific situations are worth knowing about.
Open access and the accepted manuscript
If your research is funded by UK Research and Innovation (UKRI), its open access policy affects what you do after acceptance, and it begins with how you submit. The policy expects authors to include a rights retention statement in the submission, and to make the Author Accepted Manuscript available through a compliant route. You can read the full requirements in the UKRI open access policy.
Why does this matter for tracked changes and clean copies? Because the Author Accepted Manuscript is the version that includes the changes resulting from peer review but without publisher branding. Keeping a tidy, final clean copy of the accepted text, free of comments and tracked changes, makes depositing it in an institutional repository straightforward. Many UK universities provide repository staff who can advise; it is worth contacting them when your paper is accepted rather than months later.
To check what a particular publisher allows for self-archiving, UK researchers often consult the Sherpa Romeo database, which summarises publisher policies on depositing versions of articles.
Funder acknowledgement and statements
Some funders require specific statements in the acknowledgements or data availability sections. If these statements changed during revision, show the changes in the tracked version and mention them in the response letter, so the editor does not have to discover them.
Thesis corrections after a viva
Outside journal publishing, UK doctoral students meet the same ideas after the viva. Examiners may request minor or major corrections, and universities commonly ask candidates to submit a corrected thesis along with a list or report of corrections. Practices differ between institutions: some want a tracked changes version, some want a summary table, some want both, and some require the final bound or electronic copy to be clean. Check your graduate school’s regulations and ask your supervisor or research degrees office which format is expected before you start editing.
The principles from this guide carry across: keep the original, track the revision in a working copy, produce a clean final copy, and make sure any report of corrections matches what you actually changed.
UK spelling, formatting and conventions
If you are submitting to a UK-based journal, check whether it uses British English spelling and a particular reference style. Set the document’s proofing language to English (UK) so that spell-check does not mark correct UK spellings as errors, and so that new text you add during revision follows the same convention as the rest of the paper. Inconsistency between British and American spelling is a common source of tracked-change clutter when a copy-editor later standardises the text, so settle it early.
12. Final pre-upload checklist
Use this list immediately before you upload. Tick each item.
Tracked changes version
- Created from the original submitted version, not from scratch
- Track Changes was on for the whole revision
- All Markup view shows only genuine edits, with no stray formatting noise
- No internal or draft comments remain (unless the journal asks for them)
- Author names on tracked changes are appropriate (anonymised if required)
- Moved text is explained in the response letter
Clean copy
- Generated from the final tracked version
- All changes accepted (Accept All Changes, not just those shown)
- Track Changes switched off
- All comments deleted
- Highlighting removed
- Document Inspector run on a copy; hidden data and personal information removed where required
- Fields, cross-references, figure numbers and reference list updated
- Compared with the tracked version and confirmed identical in wording
Response letter
- Every reviewer comment answered, including minor ones
- Page or line references match the version named in the letter
- Every promised change exists in the manuscript
- Tone polite, specific and evidence-based
Submission details
- File types selected correctly in the submission system
- File names clear and consistent
- Updated figures, tables and supplementary files uploaded
- Declarations (funding, conflicts, ethics, data) updated
- All co-authors have approved the final version
- Submitted within the deadline, or an extension agreed in writing
13. When to ask for professional help
Many researchers handle tracked changes and clean copies themselves with no difficulty. Professional support is worth considering in a few situations:
- the revision is extensive and you are short of time
- reviewers have raised conflicting points and you need an outside view on how to answer
- English is an additional language and you want the revised text and the response letter polished
- the previous round led to rejection and you do not want to repeat the same issues
- you are juggling a teaching load, funder deadlines and resubmission at once
At Writers.ng we help researchers prepare complete resubmission packages, from analysing reviewer comments to producing a precise marked-up manuscript and a matching clean copy. Depending on what you need, the relevant services are:
- Manuscript revision and editing for the revised text itself
- Reviewer comments analysis to structure and prioritise what the reviewers asked for
- Response letter writing for a point-by-point reply that is clear and respectful
- Rebuttal letter help where you need to push back with evidence
- Major revisions support for large-scale rewrites
If your paper was rejected rather than returned for revision, our guide to what to do after journal rejection explains your options. And if you are unsure whether the editor has invited a revision or a fresh submission, read revise and resubmit vs reject and resubmit. When you need a model for the letter itself, browse our response to reviewers examples or start from a ready response to reviewers template.
Our support is delivered online, so researchers in the UK and elsewhere can work with us regardless of location, with files exchanged securely. Your data and unpublished findings remain yours, and we will agree confidentiality terms with you before you share your manuscript.
14. Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between tracked changes and a clean copy?
A tracked changes file shows every edit you made, with insertions and deletions marked. A clean copy shows the final text with all markup removed. They contain the same wording. Journals ask for both so reviewers can see what changed and editors and production teams can work from the finished text.
Do I always need to submit both versions?
No. Requirements vary. Many journals ask for both, some ask only for a marked-up version, and a few accept a clean version plus a response letter that quotes changes. Always follow the instructions in your decision email and the journal’s author guidelines.
Should my response letter refer to the tracked or the clean version?
Check the journal’s instructions. If none are given, referring to the clean revised manuscript is common, because that is the version that will be published, but state clearly in the letter which version your page and line numbers refer to.
How do I make a clean copy from a tracked changes document in Word?
Save a separate copy, go to Review > Accept > Accept All Changes, switch off Track Changes, delete all comments, remove any highlighting, and run the Document Inspector on a copy to clear hidden data. Then proofread the result.
What if I forgot to turn on Track Changes?
Use Word’s Compare feature. Select your original submitted file as the original and your revised file as the revised one. Word will produce a document showing the differences as tracked changes. Check it carefully before uploading, because tables and reference fields can produce untidy results.
Can I use highlighting instead of tracked changes?
Only if the journal allows it. Highlighting shows new text but not deleted text, so many reviewers find it less informative. If the journal asks for highlighting, follow that instruction. If it asks for tracked changes, supply tracked changes.
Will reviewers see my name in the tracked changes?
They can, if your user name is stored in Word and the journal uses double-anonymous review. Before submitting, check the author names attached to tracked changes and comments, and run the Document Inspector on the final files to remove personal information from the document properties.
How many rounds of revision are normal?
It varies by journal and field. Some papers are accepted after one round, others need two or three. Each round follows the same pattern, so the process described here applies each time. Our article on how long to resubmit after revisions covers timing.
Does the clean copy need line numbers?
If the journal requires line numbers for review, add them to both versions. Some journals remove them for production, but they are usually needed while the paper is under review. Follow the journal’s template.
What do I do with figures and tables that changed?
Upload revised figures as separate files in the format the journal requires, and update tables in both manuscript versions. In the response letter, state which figures and tables changed and where the changes are.
Is a tracked changes file the same as a response to reviewers?
No. The response to reviewers is a separate document that answers every comment point by point. The tracked changes file is the manuscript itself with its edits visible. You need both, and they must agree with each other.
What if reviewers disagree with each other?
Address each comment, explain your reasoning, and where the reviewers conflict, say how you resolved the conflict and, if necessary, ask the editor for guidance. We cover this in conflicting reviewer comments.
Can Writers.ng prepare my tracked changes and clean copy?
Yes. We can revise the manuscript, prepare the marked-up and clean versions, and write a response letter that matches them. See our manuscript revision and editing page for details.