You open the decision email. The editor has invited a revision, which is good news. Then you reach Reviewer 2, and one comment stops you cold. The reviewer says your sampling method is inadequate, or that your central argument is wrong, or that you should have cited a paper that has nothing to do with your question. You are fairly sure the reviewer has misread your work, or simply holds a different view from yours.
What now?
Many authors respond in one of two ways, and both are mistakes. Some give in completely, rewriting good work to satisfy a comment that was never right. Others reply in anger, and a few lines of sharp language undo months of careful research. There is a third path: disagree clearly, respectfully and with evidence. Editors see this done well every week, and it very often works.
This guide explains how to disagree with a reviewer politely, step by step. It is written for researchers submitting to UK journals and to international journals that follow UK and COPE publication-ethics standards, including the many Nigerian and African authors who submit to them. You will find a decision method, twelve phrases you can adapt, five worked examples, a response-letter template and an FAQ.
If you want a broader overview of the whole process first, start with our pillar guide on responding to reviewers. To see how a full letter is put together, see our response to reviewers template and response to reviewers examples.
The short answer
To disagree with a reviewer politely:
- Wait 24 to 48 hours before drafting anything.
- Check whether the reviewer is actually wrong, or whether your manuscript was unclear.
- Thank the reviewer for the point, even when you will not follow it.
- Restate the concern fairly, in terms the reviewer would recognise.
- Agree with whatever you honestly can, then explain your position.
- Back your position with evidence: data, a published source, a journal policy or your own methodology.
- Offer a middle path where possible, such as a clarification, a limitation statement or an extra analysis.
- Show the change in the manuscript, with page and line numbers.
- Keep the tone neutral, and keep any emotion out of the letter.
- Raise unresolvable disputes with the editor, not with the reviewer.
The rest of this article explains each step in detail.
Why disagreeing with a reviewer is normal and allowed
First, a reassurance. Reviewers are experts, but they are not infallible, and editors know it.
Reviewers read your paper once or twice, often in a short window, alongside their own teaching, research and administration. They are usually unpaid. They sometimes work outside their exact specialism, and they bring their own methodological preferences to the task. Misunderstandings happen. So do reasonable differences of opinion.
Publisher guidance reflects this. Taylor & Francis Author Services advises authors to treat reviewers with respect, to respond to every point, and to explain clearly where they have not made a requested change, noting that reviewers’ comments can improve work in ways authors do not immediately appreciate (How to respond to reviewer comments, Taylor & Francis Author Services). Springer Nature’s editorial team describes the rebuttal letter as the author’s opportunity to reply directly to reviewers, clear up misunderstandings and defend aspects of the work (How to write a rebuttal letter, Springer Nature Communities).
In other words, defending your work is a legitimate part of the process. What editors object to is not disagreement. It is disagreement that is careless, unsupported, evasive or rude.
You are also protected by the ethical framework around peer review. The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) expects reviewers to be objective and constructive, to avoid hostile or inflammatory language, and to give feedback that helps authors improve their work (COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers). COPE’s guidance for editors also expects journals to have a declared way for authors to appeal editorial decisions (COPE). A polite, reasoned disagreement is part of a healthy system, not a challenge to it.
Step 1: Pause before you write anything
The first draft of a response to an annoying comment is almost never the one you should send. Read the decision letter, then close it. Come back after a day or two.
Why? Because a comment that feels like an attack at 9 a.m. often reads as a fair, if clumsy, question at 9 a.m. the next day. Delay does not mean avoidance. It means you answer the scientific content of the comment rather than your first emotional reaction to it.
During this pause, do three practical things:
- Copy every comment into a working document, numbered by reviewer and point (R1.1, R1.2, R2.1 and so on).
- Mark the easy wins. Typos, missing references, unclear figure labels and similar points can be fixed without argument. Fixing these quickly earns you goodwill for the harder points.
- Flag the genuinely contested points. These are the only ones that need the careful approach described below.
Step 2: Decide whether the reviewer is actually wrong
This is the most important step, and the one authors skip most often. Before writing a single word of disagreement, test your own position honestly. Ask yourself:
- Would a smart reader outside my subfield misunderstand this passage in the same way?
- Did I explain my method, assumptions or definitions clearly in the manuscript?
- Is the reviewer’s concern valid, even if their suggested fix is not?
- Am I resisting because the comment is wrong, or because the fix is a lot of work?
Most contested comments fall into one of five types. Each calls for a different response.
Type 1: The reviewer misunderstood
The reviewer says you did not do something you did, or reads your claim as stronger or different from what you meant.
Usual response: Politely clarify, point to where the issue is addressed, and revise the manuscript so that no future reader can make the same mistake. If one reviewer misread it, others will too. The misunderstanding is a signal about your writing, not just about the reviewer.
Type 2: Valid concern, different solution
The reviewer has spotted a real weakness, but the remedy they propose is not the right one.
Usual response: Agree that the concern is valid, explain why you are not taking the suggested route, and describe the alternative you have taken.
Type 3: Legitimate difference of interpretation or method
Reasonable experts could disagree. For example, you used a qualitative approach where the reviewer prefers a quantitative one, or you interpret a finding through one theoretical lens where they favour another.
Usual response: Defend your choice with reasons and citations, acknowledge the alternative, and add a short note in the limitations or discussion section.
Type 4: A request that is out of scope or impractical
The reviewer asks for a new dataset, a follow-up study, a different population or a doubling of the paper’s length.
Usual response: Explain, with specifics, why this lies beyond the scope of the current study, and offer to mention it as a limitation or a direction for future research.
Type 5: The reviewer is factually wrong
The comment contains an error you can demonstrate, such as a misquoted statistic, a misattributed claim or a misapplied test.
Usual response: Correct the record calmly, with the evidence in front of the reader. Do not make the reviewer look foolish. Make the correct information easy to see.
Step 3: Know the ground rules of a good rebuttal
Whatever the type of disagreement, a few rules hold. They are consistent across the publisher guidance from Taylor & Francis, Springer Nature and Elsevier. Elsevier’s author guidance, for example, encourages authors to treat peer review as a gift, to take time before responding and to respond to each point (How to respond to reviewer comments: the CALM way, Elsevier).
Respond to every point. Springer Nature’s guidance warns against ignoring specific requests or answering only the easy ones. Selective answering reads as evasion.
Never reword the reviewer’s comment to make it easier to answer. Quote it as written. Changing the meaning, even slightly, damages trust. The same Springer Nature advice cautions against rephrasing a referee’s point so that it has a convenient new meaning.
Thank the reviewers, briefly and sincerely. A short thank-you at the start of the letter, and a brief acknowledgement of each difficult point, sets a constructive tone.
Keep emotion out of the letter. The letter is a professional document. In some journals it may be published alongside the paper as part of open or transparent peer review, so write as if a wider audience may read it.
Make the reviewer’s job easy. Reviewers are volunteers. Taylor & Francis points out that the response should let them check changes with minimal effort. Use point-by-point numbering, quote the changed text, and give page and line numbers.
Step 4: A five-part structure for any contested comment
For each point where you disagree, a simple five-part structure keeps your response clear and courteous. Think of it as A-C-E-S-S: Acknowledge, Clarify, Evidence, Show, Summarise.
- Acknowledge the reviewer’s concern and thank them.
- Clarify your position and the reasoning behind it, in neutral language.
- Evidence: give data, a citation, a methodological source or a policy.
- Show what you changed in the manuscript, even if the change is only a clarification.
- Summarise in one sentence, which helps both reviewer and editor.
Here it is in a skeleton form:
Reviewer 2, Comment 4: [Quote the comment exactly.]
Response: We thank the reviewer for raising this point. [Acknowledge.] We have considered it carefully. [Clarify your position.] In our view, [reason], because [evidence or citation]. [Show.] To make this clearer for readers, we have added the following sentence to the Methods (page X, lines Y to Z): “[new text]”. [Summarise.] We hope this explains our approach, and we are happy to provide further detail if helpful.
This structure works because it is respectful, specific and verifiable. It never says “the reviewer is wrong.” It says, in effect, “here is our reasoning, here is the evidence, and here is what we changed to make it clearer.”
Twelve polite phrases for disagreeing with a reviewer
Language matters. The same disagreement can sound collaborative or combative depending on a handful of words. Adapt these phrases to your own voice and discipline.
To open a point of disagreement
- “We thank the reviewer for this thoughtful comment and have considered it carefully.”
- “We appreciate the reviewer’s concern and agree that this is an important issue.”
- “We understand why the manuscript may have given this impression.”
To state your position
- “We have respectfully taken a different approach here, for the following reasons.”
- “Our reading of the literature differs slightly, and we would like to explain why.”
- “We believe the current approach is better suited to our research question because…”
To add evidence
- “This choice is consistent with [author, year], who argue that…”
- “As shown in Table 2, the results remain stable under this assumption.”
To offer a middle path
- “While we have not made the suggested change, we have added a note to the limitations section acknowledging this alternative.”
- “We agree this would be valuable, but it lies beyond the scope of the present study. We have flagged it as a direction for future research.”
To close
- “We hope this clarifies our reasoning, and we are glad to provide further information if the reviewer or editor would find it useful.”
- “We are grateful for the opportunity to improve the manuscript in response to this feedback.”
Words and tones to avoid
Some phrases quietly damage your case. Avoid:
| Avoid | Why it backfires | Say this instead |
|---|---|---|
| “The reviewer clearly did not read the paper.” | Accuses rather than clarifies. | “We apologise if this was not sufficiently clear, and have revised page X.” |
| “This comment is wrong.” | Confrontational and absolute. | “We respectfully see this differently, for the following reasons.” |
| “We refuse to change this.” | Closes the conversation. | “We have retained this approach because…” |
| “The reviewer is not qualified to judge.” | Personal and risky. | Raise concerns about expertise, if any, privately with the editor. |
Five worked examples
These examples are illustrative. Swap in your own details, evidence and discipline. They are designed to show tone and structure, not to be copied word for word.
Example 1: The reviewer misunderstood your method
Reviewer 1, Comment 2: “The authors did not control for age in the analysis, which seriously limits the validity of the findings.”
Response: We thank the reviewer for raising this important point. We recognise that our description may have been unclear. Age was included as a covariate in all regression models (Model 2 onwards, Table 3). We have now stated this explicitly in the Methods section (page 9, lines 14 to 17) and added a footnote to Table 3 so that this is clear at first reading. We are grateful for the comment, which has helped us improve the presentation.
Notice what this does. It does not say “you missed it.” It takes responsibility for clarity, points to the evidence and fixes the manuscript.
Example 2: A request for extra experiments or data
Reviewer 2, Comment 5: “The study would be much stronger if the authors collected data from a second site.”
Response: We agree that multi-site data would add value, and we thank the reviewer for the suggestion. Unfortunately, collecting data from a second site is not feasible within the scope of this study, which was designed and ethically approved as a single-site investigation. We have therefore added a statement to the Limitations section (page 18, lines 3 to 8) acknowledging that findings may not generalise beyond this setting, and we identify multi-site replication as a priority for future work.
This is a classic middle path. It does not dismiss the suggestion. It explains the constraint and offers a limitation statement.
Example 3: A difference of methodological preference
Reviewer 1, Comment 7: “A quantitative survey would have been more appropriate than semi-structured interviews.”
Response: We appreciate the reviewer’s perspective. We chose semi-structured interviews because our research question concerns how participants experience and interpret the policy change, which is difficult to capture through fixed-response items (see Braun and Clarke, 2006, on the suitability of qualitative approaches for exploring meaning). We acknowledge that a survey would allow broader generalisation, and we have added this to the Limitations (page 17, lines 20 to 25). We have also strengthened the Methods section with a clearer rationale for our design (page 7, lines 5 to 14).
Example 4: A reviewer demands you change your conclusion
Reviewer 2, Comment 9: “The conclusion that the intervention was effective is not supported.”
Response: We thank the reviewer for their careful reading. We have re-examined the evidence for our conclusion. The primary outcome showed a statistically significant improvement (mean difference 4.2, 95% CI 1.8 to 6.6, p = 0.001; Table 4), and this was robust to the sensitivity analyses reported in Supplementary Table S2. We accept, however, that secondary outcomes were more mixed, and that our abstract may have overstated the case. We have therefore softened the wording in the Abstract and Discussion (page 2, lines 15 to 17; page 14, lines 8 to 12) to reflect that the intervention was effective for the primary outcome, with more modest evidence on secondary outcomes.
This is a strong example of conceding partially while holding the line on the central claim. Editors respond well to this kind of calibration.
Example 5: A comment about English or the authors’ background
Reviewer 3, Comment 12: “The English is poor and the authors should have the paper edited by a native speaker.”
Response: We thank the reviewer for the comment on language. We have had the manuscript carefully proofread and edited for clarity and grammar, and the changes are visible in the tracked-changes version. We would be grateful if the reviewer could point to any passages that remain unclear.
Comments about English can be reasonable if they identify specific unclear passages. When they do not, or when they become comments about the authors’ nationality or institution rather than the writing, see the section on biased comments below. If you would like professional language support, our manuscript revision and editing service keeps the authorship and the science entirely yours.
When the reviewer is rude, dismissive or biased
Most reviewers are courteous. A minority are not. If you receive a sarcastic or dismissive comment:
- Respond to the science, not the tone. Quietly ignore the sarcasm and answer the substance.
- Do not copy the tone. Sharp replies tend to harm the author more than the reviewer.
- Tell the editor if a comment crosses a line. COPE’s guidance says reviewers should not be hostile or inflammatory, and its code for editors expects them to remove offensive or libellous remarks before sending comments to authors. If something slipped through, a short, factual note to the editor is appropriate.
Comments that target your nationality, institution, gender, accent or English proficiency, rather than the content of the paper, are more serious. COPE’s reviewer guidelines state that reviews should not be influenced by the origins of a manuscript or by the nationality, religion, politics or gender of the authors (COPE). Do not absorb such a comment into your response letter as though it were fair. Instead, write to the editor separately, calmly and factually, quoting the comment and asking that it be disregarded. Keep the tone professional and avoid accusations.
This matters for researchers in Nigeria and elsewhere in Africa who submit to UK and international journals. You deserve to have your work judged on its evidence and argument. If you think a review has been unfair, you have the right to say so through the proper channels.
What if two reviewers disagree with each other?
It is common for Reviewer 1 to ask you to cut something that Reviewer 2 asks you to expand. In that case you are not disagreeing with a reviewer so much as choosing between two of them.
The recommended approach is to say so openly, explain which route you have taken and why, and ask the editor to confirm if they would prefer otherwise. Never quietly satisfy one reviewer and ignore the other. We cover this in detail in our guide to conflicting reviewer comments.
Disagreeing with the editor’s decision
Sometimes the disagreement is not with a single comment but with the overall decision. You may have been rejected after a review that seemed to miss the point.
First, be realistic. Editors reverse decisions rarely, and only with strong grounds. A good reason to appeal might be a demonstrable factual error in the review, a reviewer’s clear conflict of interest, or evidence that the review process did not follow the journal’s stated procedures. Disappointment alone is not enough.
If you do appeal:
- Check the journal’s appeals policy first. Many journals publish one, and COPE’s guidance for editors says journals should provide a declared appeal mechanism (COPE).
- Write to the editor, not the reviewers.
- Be brief, factual and specific. Identify the exact points where you believe the review was in error, and attach evidence.
Springer Nature’s editorial team notes that where an initial decision was negative and referees asked for a lot of additional information, a sensible first step before any revision may be an appeal or a letter to the editor to check whether the proposed additional work is likely to resolve the referees’ concerns (Springer Nature Communities). For what to do next, see our guides on revise and resubmit versus reject and resubmit and what to do after a journal rejection.
Showing your disagreement in the revised manuscript
A common mistake is to argue the point in the letter and change nothing in the paper. That leaves the reader, and the next reviewer, with the same confusion.
Ask yourself: if I had to explain this to the reviewer, should the explanation also be in the paper? Often the answer is yes. Even where you decline a change, you can usually:
- add a sentence of justification to the Methods or Discussion;
- add a limitation acknowledging the alternative;
- add a citation that supports your choice;
- revise a heading, definition or figure caption to remove ambiguity.
These small edits show good faith and turn a disagreement into an improvement. Our guide to tracked changes and clean copy explains how to present these edits so that editors and reviewers can follow them easily.
A response-letter template for contested comments
Here is a template you can adapt for the contested section of a letter.
Dear Dr [Editor's name],
Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript, "[Title]" (Manuscript ID: [number]). We are grateful to you and the reviewers for the thoughtful and constructive feedback.
We have addressed every comment below. Reviewers' comments appear in bold, our responses in regular text, and changes to the manuscript are shown in the tracked-changes file with page and line numbers referring to the revised version.
REVIEWER 1
Comment 1.1
[Quote comment exactly.]
Response: [Thank, agree where possible, state the change made.]
...
Comment 1.4 (point of respectful disagreement)
[Quote comment exactly.]
Response: We thank the reviewer for this comment and have considered it carefully. [Acknowledge the concern fairly.] We have respectfully retained our original approach because [reason], consistent with [citation]. To address the concern, we have [clarified / added a limitation / added an analysis] (page X, lines Y to Z). We hope this is acceptable.
REVIEWER 2
...
Once again, we thank you and the reviewers for the time and care devoted to our work. We hope the revised manuscript is now suitable for publication in [Journal name].
Yours sincerely,
[Corresponding author, on behalf of all authors]
For a fuller walk-through, see our response to reviewers template and our guide on how to respond to major revisions.
Special considerations for UK journals and UK-based research
If you are targeting UK journals, or journals that follow UK norms, several points are worth keeping in mind.
Research integrity frameworks apply. UK institutions work within the Concordat to Support Research Integrity, which UKRI describes in its research integrity hub (UKRI research integrity). The UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO), an independent charity, offers advice on good practice in research, including publication and peer review (UKRIO). If you believe a peer-review process has involved misconduct, rather than ordinary disagreement, these are the kinds of organisations that publish relevant guidance. For the journal side, COPE’s flowcharts and guidelines are the standard reference.
Medical and health journals often follow ICMJE standards. The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors sets out the responsibilities of authors, reviewers and editors in the submission and peer-review process (ICMJE Recommendations: Roles and Responsibilities). If you are submitting to a journal that follows ICMJE, it is worth reading the relevant sections so that your tone and approach match the journal’s expectations.
For authors in Nigeria and across Africa
Many of the researchers who come to Writers.ng are writing from Nigerian universities, teaching hospitals and research institutes, and submitting to UK, European and international journals. A few additional pointers apply.
- Do not accept language bias as inevitable. If a reviewer’s comment focuses on your English rather than on specific unclear passages, ask politely for examples, and consider professional language editing so that language is never the reason a good paper is held back.
- Be explicit about local context. If your study is set in a Nigerian health system, school system or market, and a reviewer questions generalisability, explain why the local context is the point of the study, and why it is valuable, not a limitation. Cite regional literature to support the case.
Common mistakes when disagreeing with reviewers
Even careful authors fall into these traps.
- Responding too quickly. A rushed reply usually sounds either defensive or flustered.
- Arguing without evidence. “We believe our approach is correct” is an opinion. A citation, a table or a policy is an argument.
- Ignoring the comment. Silence is worse than disagreement.
- Changing the manuscript but not telling the reviewer. Every change should be flagged.
- Missing the deadline. A late, perfect reply can be worse than a timely, good one. If you need more time, ask the editor early. Our guide on how long you have to resubmit after revisions covers typical timelines.
A quick checklist before you submit
Before you send your letter, check that:
- Every comment has a numbered response.
- Every reviewer comment is quoted exactly as written.
- Every disagreement is supported by evidence or a citation.
- Every claimed change appears in the manuscript, with page and line numbers.
- You have thanked the editor and reviewers sincerely.
- A co-author or trusted colleague has read the letter.
- You have followed the journal’s instructions on format and deadlines.
- Tracked-changes and clean versions match.
Further reading and resources
These independent resources are worth bookmarking.
- Taylor & Francis Author Services: How to respond to reviewer comments
- Springer Nature Communities: How to write a rebuttal letter
- Elsevier Author Update: How to respond to reviewer comments: the CALM way
- Pat Thomson (academic writing blog): What did that peer reviewer actually mean?
- COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics): Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers and the COPE website
- UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO): ukrio.org
- UKRI: Research integrity
- ICMJE: Roles and Responsibilities of Authors, Contributors, Reviewers, Editors, Publishers, and Owners
When to ask for professional help
Most authors can handle most reviewer comments on their own, especially with the structure above. But some situations benefit from a second pair of eyes:
- A decision with a long list of major revisions.
- A reviewer comment that you cannot decide whether to accept or contest.
- A tight deadline.
- A tone problem, where your draft sounds too sharp or too apologetic.
- English-language polish for the response letter or the revised manuscript.
At Writers.ng, our editors help researchers organise and improve their own revisions and responses. We do not alter your data, invent results or write your science for you. You remain the author, and every decision about your research is yours. If you would like support, take a look at our services:
- Response letter writing service
- Major revisions help
- Rebuttal letter help
- Reviewer comments analysis
- Manuscript revision and editing
Frequently asked questions
Can I disagree with a reviewer in my response letter?
Yes. Disagreeing is a normal and accepted part of peer review, provided you do it respectfully, with evidence, and without ignoring the underlying concern. Editors expect authors to engage with reviewers’ points, not to agree with every one of them.
Will disagreeing with a reviewer get my paper rejected?
Not if you do it well. Editors are usually more concerned with whether you have taken the reviewers seriously than with whether you have agreed with all of them. A reasoned, evidence-based disagreement, accompanied by clear changes elsewhere, is often accepted. A dismissive or unsupported one is risky.
What should I do if the reviewer is simply wrong?
Say so gently. Provide the evidence, such as a table, a citation or a method description, that shows the correct position, and revise the manuscript so the point cannot be misread again. Do not suggest that the reviewer was careless. A phrase such as “We apologise that this was not sufficiently clear” is usually better than “The reviewer overlooked this.”
Should I contact the reviewer directly?
No. In almost all journals, communication goes through the editor. COPE’s guidance says reviewers should not contact authors directly without the journal’s permission, and authors should likewise route concerns through the editor.
What if a reviewer asks me to cite their own work?
Cite it if it is relevant and improves your paper. If it is not, politely explain why you have not included it. If you believe the request is purely to inflate citations, raise it, calmly and factually, with the editor, and look at COPE’s guidance on the subject.
Can Writers.ng write my response to reviewers for me?
We can help you analyse comments, plan your responses, structure the letter, improve clarity and tone, and edit your revised manuscript. The research, the data and the decisions remain yours, as academic integrity requires.
Learning how to disagree with a reviewer politely is one of the most useful skills in academic publishing. It protects your work from unfair or mistaken criticism, and it shows editors that you are a thoughtful, professional colleague.
Ready to take the next step? Explore our full guide to responding to reviewers, or get in touch with Writers.ng for help with your response letter.
Writers.ng provides academic writing, editing and revision support to students, researchers and professionals in Nigeria and internationally. All work is delivered in line with academic integrity standards. Authors remain responsible for their own research, data and conclusions.
Related reading: Response to reviewers template | Response to reviewers examples | How to respond to major revisions | Conflicting reviewer comments | Tracked changes and clean copy