Response to Reviewers Template: A Free Letter Format for UK Researchers (With Phrases and Examples)

Qualitative vs Quantitative Dissertation: Which Should You Choose? | Writers.ng

Part of the Response to Reviewers guide from Writers.ng.

You have opened the decision email. The editor has not rejected your paper, which is good news, but the reviewers have left pages of comments and the journal wants a revised manuscript and a response to reviewers within a few weeks. Your first reaction may be irritation, or a sinking feeling that you have misjudged your own work. That is normal. What matters now is the document that will sit beside your revised paper: the response to reviewers letter.

This guide gives you a complete response to reviewers template you can copy, adapt and use today. It is written for researchers submitting to UK and international journals, whether you are a PhD student at a UK university, an early-career researcher on a UKRI-funded project, a clinician-researcher, or an international author aiming at a British journal. You will find a ready-made structure, sentence banks for every awkward situation (agreeing, partly agreeing, disagreeing, clarifying a misunderstanding, declining a request), a worked example, formatting advice, and a final checklist.

Table of Contents

If you want to see the template applied to realistic reviewer comments, read our companion post of response to reviewers examples. If you would rather have an experienced editor draft the letter with you, see our response letter writing service.

Key takeaways

  • A response letter is a persuasion document for the editor, not a debate with the reviewers. Its job is to make the editor’s decision easy.
  • Respond to every single comment, even the ones you disagree with, and show exactly where in the manuscript each change was made.
  • Use a consistent structure: opening note to the editor, summary of main changes, then a point-by-point reply for each reviewer.
  • Be complete, polite and evidence-based. These three rules recur across the published advice on this topic.
  • Disagree rarely, politely and with evidence. Never ignore a comment silently.
  • Submit three clean, matching documents: the response letter, the revised manuscript with changes visible, and a clean copy.

What is a response to reviewers letter?

A response to reviewers letter (also called a rebuttal letter, response letter, author response or reply to referees) is the document you submit with your revised manuscript. It lists every comment from the editor and reviewers and explains, one by one, what you did about it and where the change can be found.

It is not a cover letter for a first submission, and it is not an essay defending your paper. Editors usually read it first, often before they open the revised manuscript, and they may forward it to the original reviewers. A clear letter can speed up the decision. A defensive or incomplete one can sink a paper that was one revision away from acceptance.

It helps to understand where the letter sits in the wider process. Decisions generally fall into a handful of categories: accept, minor revisions, major revisions, revise and resubmit, and reject. The letter is relevant in every revision scenario. If you are unsure which category your decision falls into, our post on revise and resubmit vs reject and resubmit explains the differences and what each means for your next step.

What editors and reviewers expect from your response

Publisher guidance on this topic is remarkably consistent. The American Chemical Society’s author-support site advises that a strong response includes a point-by-point reply to every reviewer comment, quoting the review where necessary so the editor can see how each suggestion was handled. It also says you should respond to all comments even if you disagree with some, and flag clearly to the editor any suggestions you chose not to follow. You can read the full advice in the ACS guide on how to respond to reviewer comments.

A frequently cited paper from a UK academic, Professor Hywel Williams of the University of Nottingham, boils the task down to three golden rules: respond completely, respond politely and respond with evidence. His article, How to reply to referees’ comments when submitting manuscripts for publication, is short, practical and worth reading in full. It also makes the point that responding to referees requires the writer to set aside any feeling of personal attack and concentrate on courteous, objective, evidence-based replies.

The F1000 researcher blog makes a complementary point about organisation. It suggests listing every change requested by the reviewers and the editor, then sorting comments into types: those you will act on, those where the reviewer needs clarification because they may have misunderstood something, and those you can politely decline. See their guide to responding to peer reviewer comments. It also reminds authors to follow the journal’s submission guidelines and to include every document requested, such as the response, the revised manuscript and any cover letter.

Put simply, editors want to see four things:

  1. Completeness. Nothing has been skipped.
  2. Traceability. Every reply points to a specific, findable change (page, paragraph, line number or section).
  3. Professional tone. You treat reviewers as colleagues who have given their time, even when the review is blunt.
  4. Good judgement. You made sensible decisions about which suggestions to adopt, adapt or decline, and you can justify them.

Before you write: a five-step preparation routine

Most weak response letters are weak because they were written too soon. Spend a day or two on preparation and the writing becomes straightforward.

Step 1: Read, then pause

Read the decision letter and all reports once, then stop. Elsevier’s Researcher Academy webinar on how to respond to reviewers’ comments, presented by a publisher, recommends taking a break after receiving feedback so you can absorb it and get input from others. A 24 to 48 hour pause is usually enough to move from “they have misunderstood everything” to “some of this is fair”.

Step 2: Re-read the editor’s letter

The editor’s instructions override everything else. They may say which comments are essential, which can be treated as optional, whether a new analysis is mandatory, and what the deadline is. If the editor and a reviewer conflict, the editor’s guidance wins. Our post on conflicting reviewer comments covers how to handle contradictory advice in detail.

Step 3: Break every report into numbered comments

Reviewers write in paragraphs, not tidy bullet points. Split each report into individual, numbered comments (Reviewer 1, Comment 1.1, 1.2 and so on). One long paragraph may contain four separate requests, and you must answer each. This is the single most valuable habit in the whole process, and it is also the heart of our reviewer comments analysis service.

Step 4: Categorise and prioritise

Sort each comment into one of these categories:

  • Agree and fix: a clear error, omission or unclear passage.
  • Agree in part: the concern is valid but the suggested solution is not.
  • Clarify: the reviewer misunderstood, which usually means your text was not clear enough.
  • Cannot do: the request is impossible, outside the scope of the study, or would require data you do not have.
  • Disagree: you have a well-evidenced reason not to change the paper.

Most comments will fall into the first two groups. Treat a high number of “disagree” comments as a warning sign: if you disagree with most of the review, check whether the real problem is your framing.

Step 5: Agree a plan with your co-authors or supervisor

Decide who does what, who signs off the final letter and what the deadline is. For PhD students at UK universities, this usually means talking to your supervisory team before you send anything, especially if you plan to decline a major request. The corresponding author is responsible for the letter, but every author should see it before it is submitted.

The anatomy of a strong response letter

Whatever journal you are targeting, the following structure works almost everywhere. Always check the author guidelines first, because some journals use their own online form or ask for a table.

  1. Title block: manuscript title, manuscript ID, journal name and the corresponding author.
  2. Opening note to the editor: a short, warm thank-you and a one-paragraph summary of the revision.
  3. Summary of main changes (optional but helpful for major revisions): three to six bullets showing the biggest improvements.
  4. Point-by-point responses to the editor’s comments (if the editor raised any).
  5. Point-by-point responses to Reviewer 1, then Reviewer 2, and so on, each with the original comment quoted, your response, and the location of the change.
  6. Closing note: thanks and a statement that you hope the revised paper is now suitable for publication.

A widely used layout puts each reviewer comment in one colour (often black or bold), your response in another (blue is common) and any text copied from the manuscript in a third (often in italics or in a boxed quotation). That makes the letter scannable. Some authors prefer a three-column table with the columns “Reviewer comment”, “Author response” and “Location of change”. Both work. Pick one and use it throughout.

The response to reviewers template (copy and adapt)

Copy the text below into a Word document and replace everything in square brackets. Keep the numbering. If the journal supplies its own response form, follow the journal’s version and use this text as your wording guide.

Response to Reviewers

Manuscript title: [Full title] Manuscript ID: [ID] Journal: [Journal name] Corresponding author: [Name, institution]

Dear Dr [Editor surname] and Reviewers,

Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript, and for the careful and constructive reviews. We found the comments very helpful and have revised the paper accordingly. Below we respond to each point in turn. Reviewer comments are shown in bold, our responses in regular text, and revised or new text from the manuscript in italics. Page and line numbers refer to the revised manuscript with tracked changes.

Summary of the main changes

  1. [Biggest change, for example: We added a new analysis addressing the concern about [issue] (Section 3.2, Table 4).]
  2. [Second change.]
  3. [Third change.]
  4. [Clarified the study aims and the contribution to the literature (Introduction, pp. 2-3).]

Editor’s comments

Comment E1: [Paste the editor’s comment exactly.]

Response: [Your reply.]

Change made: [Page, paragraph or line number, with the new text if short.]

Reviewer 1

We thank Reviewer 1 for [specific positive comment, for example the thoughtful reading of our methods].

Comment 1.1: [Paste the comment exactly.]

Response: [Thank the reviewer, state what you did, and say why.]

Change made: [Page and line, or Section and paragraph. Paste new text where practical.]

Comment 1.2: [Paste the comment exactly.]

Response: [Your reply.]

Change made: [Location.]

(Continue for every comment.)

Reviewer 2

Comment 2.1: [Paste the comment exactly.]

Response: [Your reply.]

Change made: [Location.]

(Continue for every comment.)

Closing note

We hope that the revised manuscript now meets the standard of [Journal name] and we are grateful to the editor and reviewers for helping us to improve it. We would be happy to make any further changes you consider necessary.

Yours sincerely, [Name, on behalf of all authors]

Why this template works

The quoted comment proves you read the exact words and lets the editor see the issue without flipping between documents. The “Change made” line is the most important element, because it turns a promise into evidence. The summary of main changes helps a busy editor who wants to know whether the paper has materially improved before reading dozens of replies.

Tone and language: how to sound professional, not defensive

Tone is where many otherwise good letters fail. Remember who is reading. The editor wants a decision they can defend. Reviewers have usually volunteered unpaid time. Your paper is not on trial, and the reviewers are not enemies.

The ACS guidance mentioned above offers a useful rule of thumb: if the review you receive does not seem friendly, still respond as if it is. Professional peer-review ethics support this expectation from the other side as well. The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) publishes ethical guidelines for peer reviewers, and its wider core practices set the standards that many journals sign up to. Reviewers are expected to be objective and constructive, which means editors will be alert to any hostile or sarcastic tone in your reply too.

A few practical rules:

  • Thank, but do not grovel. One genuine thank-you per reviewer is enough. Do not begin every reply with “Thank you for this excellent comment”.
  • Say what you did, not how you feel. “We have added…” beats “We apologise for the oversight…”.
  • Avoid absolutes such as “clearly”, “obviously” and “the reviewer is wrong”.
  • Never blame the reviewer for a misunderstanding. Assume the text was unclear. “We have clarified…” is always better than “The reviewer has overlooked…”.
  • Use “we” and the active voice. It is warmer and clearer.
  • Keep each reply proportionate. A one-line fix gets a one-line reply.

The sentence bank: phrases for every situation

Use these as starting points and adjust them to your own discipline and voice.

Opening and thanking

  • “We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion.”
  • “We are grateful to the reviewer for drawing our attention to this point.”
  • “This is an important observation, and we have revised the manuscript accordingly.”

Agreeing and making the change

  • “We agree and have revised the paragraph to [specific change] (page X, lines Y to Z).”
  • “We have added a new subsection, 2.4, which explains [topic] (page X).”
  • “The reviewer is right that [issue]. We have corrected this in Table 2 and in the text on page X.”
  • “We have added the suggested references [list] and discussed their relevance in the Discussion (page X).”

Agreeing in part

  • “We agree that [concern] deserves attention. However, a full [analysis or experiment] is beyond the scope of this study because [reason]. Instead, we have [alternative action] and acknowledged the limitation on page X.”
  • “We have adopted the first part of this suggestion. For the second part, we considered [option], but chose [alternative] because [reason].”

Clarifying a misunderstanding

  • “We apologise that this was not clear in our original text. We have rewritten the paragraph to make explicit that [clarification] (page X, lines Y to Z).”
  • “We believe this may reflect an ambiguity in how we described the sample. We have added a sentence to the Methods to make this clear.”

Respectfully disagreeing

  • “We have given this suggestion careful thought. We respectfully take a different view because [evidence-based reason, with citation]. To address the underlying concern, we have added a sentence in the Limitations section (page X).”
  • “We understand the rationale for this request. However, [specific constraint]. We hope the reviewer will agree that the revised text now makes this transparent.”

Disagreement needs its own skills, and we cover them in depth in our post on how to disagree with a reviewer politely. The short version: acknowledge the concern, give your evidence, and show what you did instead.

Explaining that something cannot be done

  • “We agree that [additional data or analysis] would strengthen the paper. Unfortunately, [reason, for example, the data were not collected / ethical approval does not cover this]. We have therefore noted this as a limitation and suggested it as a direction for future work (page X).”

A worked example: before and after

Seeing the template in use makes the difference between a weak and a strong reply obvious. The example below is invented for illustration.

Comment 1.3 (Reviewer 1): The sample size seems small and the authors do not justify it. I am not convinced the conclusions follow from so few participants.

Weak response:

We disagree. The sample size is typical for this kind of study and many published papers use fewer participants.

This reply is curt, offers no evidence, changes nothing and gives the editor no location to check. It invites a second round of criticism.

Strong response:

Response: Thank you for raising this. We agree that the justification for the sample size was missing from the original manuscript. We have added a power calculation to the Methods, which shows that 48 participants gave 80% power to detect the effect size reported in [reference]. We have also moderated our language in the Discussion, replacing “demonstrates” with “suggests”, and added the small sample to the Limitations paragraph.

Change made: Methods, Section 2.3, page 6, lines 14 to 21; Discussion, page 12, lines 3 to 6; Limitations, page 14, lines 9 to 12.

Notice what the second version does. It concedes the valid part of the criticism, supplies evidence, adjusts the claims to match the data and points to three specific places. It also avoids any hint that the reviewer was foolish. That is the standard to aim for in every reply.

Want more samples across different disciplines and comment types? Our response to reviewers examples post goes further.

Formatting and submission: tracked changes, clean copy and line numbers

A brilliant letter can still frustrate an editor if the files are a mess. Follow these habits.

  • Use line numbers or page-and-paragraph references. Ask yourself whether someone could find each change in under ten seconds. If not, add more precise locations.
  • Quote new text in the letter when the change is short (one to three sentences). It saves the editor from opening the manuscript for every comment.
  • Make sure the letter matches the final manuscript. If you move a paragraph during the last edit, every line number may change. Update the references only when the manuscript is final.
  • Prepare both versions of the paper. Most journals ask for one file with changes visible (tracked changes or highlighting) and one clean file. Our post on tracked changes and clean copy explains how to produce and name each correctly.
  • Check anonymisation. The F1000 guidance notes that if you submit to a journal using double-anonymised review, your revised manuscript will need to be anonymised. That includes your tracked-changes version, file properties and the wording of your response letter. Avoid phrases such as “in our previous study (Smith et al., 2022)” if that reveals your identity.
  • Follow the journal’s file requirements. Some journals want the response letter uploaded as a separate file, others as a field in the submission system. Read the instructions for authors rather than assuming.

If you want a professional to prepare matching, journal-ready files, our manuscript revision and editing service is built for exactly that stage.

Special situations that UK authors often face

Major revisions

Major revisions mean the editor sees potential but expects substantial work: new analysis, restructured arguments, additional literature or clearer methods. Do not rush. Build a timetable, agree it with co-authors and consider writing the response letter in parallel with the revision, so each comment is answered while the change is fresh. We cover the whole process in how to respond to major revisions, and if you need hands-on support there is our dedicated major revisions help page.

Reviewers who contradict each other

Reviewer 1 asks you to shorten the literature review. Reviewer 2 asks you to expand it. Do not try to satisfy both. Tell the editor about the conflict, explain the option you chose and why, and ask for guidance if the decision matters. Our guide to conflicting reviewer comments gives scripts for this situation.

PhD students and supervised research

If your paper comes from a doctoral project, your supervisors are often co-authors and may have strong views about how to respond. Share a draft early and agree who has the final word. Think too about the bigger picture: a review that feels harsh may be a useful rehearsal for the examiners who will read your thesis. Cambridge University Libraries’ short guide, Research Support Handy Guides: Demystifying Peer Review, is an accessible introduction to how peer review works if you are new to the process.

Funder requirements and open access (UKRI and others)

Revision is a good moment to check your funding and open access obligations. UKRI’s open access policy applies to peer-reviewed research articles submitted on or after 1 April 2022 and requires immediate open access, along with a rights statement applying a Creative Commons Attribution licence to the Author Accepted Manuscript. Journals will often ask you to confirm your funding acknowledgement and licence information with the revised paper, so make sure these match across the submission system, the manuscript and the response. The policy itself is on the UKRI website: UKRI open access policy. Check the current wording with your funder and your institution’s library or research office, as guidance is updated from time to time.

When the decision is a rejection

A rejection with detailed reviews is still valuable. Professor Williams argues in the Nottingham paper cited above that you should consider revising and resubmitting to the same journal where the comments are fair, and the University libraries’ guides to dealing with rejection suggest a similar sequence: read the reviewers’ comments, revise the paper appropriately, reconsider your choice of journal and then resubmit. The Indiana University scholarly publishing guide summarises this approach neatly. For next steps, see our post on what to do after journal rejection. If you plan to send the paper elsewhere, you do not usually need a point-by-point letter for the new journal, but using the reviews to improve the paper first is almost always worthwhile.

Deadlines

Journals set their own revision deadlines and the date is normally stated in the decision email. If you cannot meet it, ask the editorial office for an extension before the deadline passes rather than after. For realistic timelines by revision type, read how long to take to resubmit after revisions.

Ten common mistakes (and how to avoid them)

  1. Skipping a comment. Even if you think it is trivial, answer it. A missing reply looks like avoidance.
  2. Vague answers. “We have revised the text” with no location gives the editor nothing to check.
  3. Changing the paper but not saying so. Every substantive change should appear in the letter, and every claim in the letter should be visible in the paper.
  4. Arguing first and thanking second. Lead with what you did.
  5. Over-apologising. One short apology for a genuine lack of clarity is fine. Repeated apologies undermine your authority.
  6. Emotional language. Never answer a comment while irritated. Draft, sleep on it, edit.
  7. Ignoring the editor’s comments. The editor’s points often matter more than any single reviewer’s.
  8. Contradicting yourself. Check that the response to Reviewer 2 does not undermine a response to Reviewer 1.
  9. Inconsistent numbering and cross-references. Always check that page and line references still match the final file.
  10. Submitting the wrong files. Confirm that the clean copy and the tracked-changes copy are the same text.

Final checklist before you submit

  • Every editor and reviewer comment is numbered and answered.
  • Each reply says what changed and where.
  • Tone is courteous, evidence-based and consistent throughout.
  • Disagreements are rare, explained and backed by references.
  • New analysis, tables and figures appear in both the letter (where short) and the manuscript.
  • Line numbers and page references match the final manuscript.
  • The tracked-changes and clean manuscripts are identical in content.
  • Anonymisation, funding acknowledgements and licence statements have been checked.
  • All co-authors have read and approved the letter and the revised paper.
  • You have followed the journal’s instructions for file types and upload.

Frequently asked questions

What should a response to reviewers letter include?

A good letter includes a short opening note to the editor, an optional summary of main changes, and a point-by-point reply to every comment from the editor and each reviewer. Each reply should quote the comment, explain the action taken and give the location of the change in the revised manuscript.

How long should a response to reviewers letter be?

There is no fixed length. It should be as long as it needs to be to answer every comment completely and no longer. For a paper with two reviewers and twenty comments, six to twelve pages in a quote-and-reply format is common. Do not pad short replies and do not cut necessary evidence.

Can I disagree with a reviewer?

Yes, if you have good evidence. Respond politely, acknowledge the concern, explain your reasoning with references or data and show what you did to address the underlying worry. Never ignore the comment silently. See our guide to disagreeing with a reviewer politely.

Do I need to respond to every comment?

Yes. Publisher guidance, including the ACS advice linked above, recommends responding to all reviewer comments and telling the editor clearly about any suggestions you decided not to follow.

Should I paste the reviewer’s comments into the letter?

Usually yes. Quoting the comment lets the editor and reviewers see each point and your answer together. Some journals prefer a table. Whichever layout you use, keep it consistent.

What is the difference between a response letter and a cover letter?

A cover letter accompanies the first submission and introduces the paper. A response letter accompanies the revised paper and answers the review. Some journals also ask for a short cover letter on resubmission, so check the guidelines. The F1000 guidance notes that you should include every document the journal requests, such as the response, the revised manuscript and any cover letter.

Is it acceptable to use a template?

Yes. A template is only a structure. The content must be specific to your paper and your reviewers. Generic replies that could apply to any manuscript are easy for editors to spot.

What if I cannot do what the reviewer asks?

Explain why (for example, the data do not exist, the request is beyond the scope of the study or ethical approval does not cover it), propose a realistic alternative and acknowledge the point as a limitation in the paper.

Further reading and trusted resources

These independent resources from publishers, universities and ethics bodies expand on the points above:

Conclusion: make the editor’s decision easy

A response to reviewers letter does one job: it helps an editor say yes. You do that by being complete, polite and evidence-based, by showing exactly where every change lives, and by treating the review as a conversation rather than a contest. Use the template above as your skeleton, fill it with specific, honest answers and keep your tone steady even when the review stings.

If you are short on time, unsure how to handle a difficult reviewer, or simply want a second pair of expert eyes before you resubmit, Writers.ng can help. Explore our full response to reviewers guide and services, or go straight to the support you need: