How to Respond to Reviewer Comments on a Journal Submission (With Template)

Qualitative vs Quantitative Dissertation: Which Should You Choose? | Writers.ng

Getting a “revise and resubmit” email is good news. It means the editor sees potential in your paper. But the next step decides the outcome: your response to reviewers letter and your revised manuscript. Many papers that get a second chance are still rejected because the response was defensive, vague or incomplete.

This guide shows you exactly how to respond to reviewer comments on a journal submission: how to read the decision, organise the feedback, write a point-by-point response, handle disagreement, and submit with confidence. It includes a template you can copy.

If you are still choosing where to publish, first read our guide on how to publish in Scopus-indexed journals.

What a Reviewer Decision Really Means

DecisionWhat it meansWhat to do
AcceptNo changes neededCheck proofs and publish
Minor revisionSmall fixes (clarity, references, formatting)Respond to every point, usually quick
Major revisionSubstantial changes (analysis, framing, literature)Plan carefully; allow weeks, not days
Reject and resubmitCore problems; a new version may be reconsideredTreat as a rewrite and read the editor’s note closely
RejectPaper not suitable for this journalLearn from the comments and submit elsewhere

Most journals treat “major revision” as a real opportunity. It is not a polite rejection.

The Mindset That Gets Papers Accepted

Reviewers are usually unpublished volunteers giving their time, and editors read your response letter partly to judge how you will behave as a collaborator. Taylor & Francis Author Services stresses respecting reviewers because their comments can improve your work in ways you may not see at first. They also note that reviewers are busy and unpaid, so you should make re-reviewing as easy as possible. The ACS Axial guide gives the same practical advice: respond to every comment, even ones you disagree with, and tell the editor which suggestions you chose not to follow. taylorandfrancisacs

Step-by-Step: How to Respond to Reviewer Comments

Step 1: Read, Pause, Then Reread

Read the decision letter once, then step away for a day. Your first reaction to criticism is rarely your best. On the second read, separate the editor’s instructions from each reviewer’s comments.

Step 2: Break Every Comment Into Separate Points

Copy all comments into one document with a section for the editor and one for each reviewer. Number every point: R1.1, R1.2, R2.1 and so on. Taylor & Francis recommends keeping all changes marked with tracked changes or comment bubbles so you can find them when completing the response letter. Never merge two comments into one answer. taylorandfrancis

Step 3: Sort Points Into Categories

Build a simple table with three columns: the comment, your planned action, and your status.

CategoryTypical action
Easy fixes (typos, citations, clarity)Fix and say where
Needs new analysis or dataDo the work, report results
MisunderstandingClarify the text so others don’t misread it
You disagreeRespond politely with evidence
Cannot be done (no data, out of scope)Explain honestly and add a limitation

Step 4: Make the Changes in the Manuscript First

Revise the paper before drafting the letter. A strong letter cannot rescue a manuscript where the changes are only superficial, because reviewers read both documents. Use continuous line numbers or page references so every claim in your letter can be checked.

Step 5: Write the Point-by-Point Response Letter

Use this structure for every comment:

  1. Quote the reviewer’s comment (in bold or a coloured font).
  2. Write “Response:” and say what you did.
  3. State exactly where the change is (page and line, or section).
  4. Paste the revised text if the change is short.

Step 6: Write a Short Cover Note to the Editor

Summarise the main changes, point the editor to any disagreements, and confirm that all co-authors approved the revision.

Step 7: Proofread and Submit

Check that every comment has a response, line numbers match, new references are in the reference list, and the file names follow the journal’s instructions. Submit before the deadline, or request an extension early if you need one.

Response Letter Template (Copy and Adapt)

Dear Editor,

Thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript, “[Title]” (Manuscript ID: [number]). We are grateful to you and the reviewers for the constructive feedback. We have addressed every comment below. Reviewer comments are in bold, our responses follow in regular text, and revisions in the manuscript are highlighted in [yellow/tracked changes].

EDITOR’S COMMENTS

Comment E1: [paste comment]
Response: [your response, with page and line numbers]

REVIEWER 1

Comment 1.1: [paste comment]
Response: Thank you for this observation. We have [action]. The revised text now reads: “[new text]” (page X, lines Y–Z).

Comment 1.2: [paste comment]
Response: [response]

REVIEWER 2

Comment 2.1: [paste comment]
Response: [response]

We believe the revisions have strengthened the manuscript and hope it is now suitable for publication in [Journal Name].

Sincerely,
[Corresponding author], on behalf of all authors

Sample Responses for Hard Situations

When You Agree and Made the Change

Comment: The sample size justification is missing.
Response: Thank you. We have added the sample size calculation and its justification in Section 3.3 (page 8, lines 201–210).

When the Reviewer Misunderstood

Comment: The authors do not explain why they used a cross-sectional design.
Response: We apologise that this was unclear. We have added a paragraph in Section 3.1 (page 6, lines 148–156) explaining that a cross-sectional design suits our objective of estimating prevalence at one point in time.

Never write “the reviewer missed this.” Assume your text was unclear and fix it.

When You Respectfully Disagree

Comment: The authors should include a qualitative component.
Response: We appreciate this suggestion and agree that a qualitative component would add depth. However, our study aims to test a specific hypothesis using standardised measures, so a qualitative strand lies outside its scope and would require new ethical approval. We now acknowledge this as a limitation and a direction for future research (page 14, lines 390–396).

State your reasoning, support it with evidence or a citation, and add something to the manuscript when you can. A bare “we disagree” gets rejected.

When Reviewers Contradict Each Other

Response (to Reviewers 1 and 2): Reviewer 1 suggests shortening the introduction, while Reviewer 2 asks for more background on policy context. We reduced the general background and added a focused paragraph on the policy context, keeping the section to the same length (page 2, lines 40–72). We would welcome the editor’s guidance if a different balance is preferred.

If the conflict is serious, flag it to the editor in your cover note.

When a Reviewer Asks for Extra Data You Don’t Have

Explain what you can and cannot do, and why. Offer what you can do instead, such as a sensitivity analysis, a limitation paragraph, or a clearly labelled follow-up study.

Language and Tone Tips

  • Thank the reviewers once at the top and briefly where a comment truly helped. Do not grovel.
  • Use “we” and neutral language. Avoid “obviously,” “clearly the reviewer,” and “as we already stated.”
  • Keep disagreements factual, short and evidence-based.
  • Never ignore a comment, including minor ones.
  • Keep a consistent format so the editor can scan quickly.

Common Mistakes That Lead to Rejection

  1. Responding only in the letter and not changing the manuscript.
  2. Skipping comments you find unfair.
  3. Missing the deadline without asking for an extension.
  4. Defensive or sarcastic tone.
  5. No page or line references.
  6. Changing things in the manuscript that you do not mention (reviewers notice).
  7. Answering all reviewers in one block instead of point by point.
  8. Ignoring the editor’s own instructions, which often matter most.

Special Concerns for Nigerian and African Authors

  • Tight timelines: Many journals give 2 to 6 weeks for a major revision. Start planning the same day.
  • Co-author coordination: Agree on one corresponding author and one master file so versions don’t collide.
  • Journal quality: Before investing in a long revision, confirm the journal is genuinely indexed. Read our guide to Scopus journal publication services in Nigeria to learn how to verify claims independently.
  • Longer review cycles: Higher-tier journals often take months, and revision is common even for papers that are eventually accepted. See our notes on ISI journal publication assistance.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should a response to reviewers be?
As long as it needs to be to answer every point. Short, precise responses with exact locations are better than long essays.

Do I have to accept every reviewer suggestion?
No. You must respond to every one, but you may politely decline with evidence and explain your reasoning.

What if a reviewer is rude or unfair?
Respond professionally as if the comment were polite. Address the substance, ignore the tone, and raise serious concerns with the editor, not the reviewer.

Can I ask for more time?
Yes. Email the editor before the deadline with a short, reasonable request.

What if I disagree with the editor’s decision?
Most journals allow an appeal, but it needs a formal, evidence-based letter and rarely succeeds. Usually revising or choosing a better-fitting journal is faster.

Can someone help me draft my response?
Yes. Professional support can help you interpret comments, plan revisions and polish the letter, while you remain responsible for the science and the final content. No ethical service can guarantee acceptance, because that depends on the reviewers and the editor.

Need Help Responding to Reviewers?

Peer review is where many strong papers stall. At Writers.ng, we help Nigerian researchers interpret reviewer feedback, plan revisions and draft clear, professional responses. Explore our journal publication support services or learn how we guide researchers through Scopus-indexed publication, including peer review response and revise-and-resubmit support.

Related Guides

Further reading from publishers: