Journal Submission Checklist for Nigerian Academics
Getting a manuscript from a finished study to a published, indexed article involves dozens of small, easy-to-overlook steps — any one of which can delay or derail the entire process if missed. For Nigerian academics juggling promotion deadlines, teaching loads, and often limited institutional editorial support, having a clear, stage-by-stage checklist to work through is one of the simplest ways to avoid the avoidable mistakes that most commonly cost researchers time, money, and momentum.
This guide provides a complete journal submission checklist, organised by stage, covering everything from before you start writing through to post-publication indexing — with specific attention to the considerations that matter most for researchers publishing from Nigerian institutions.
Why a Structured Checklist Matters More in the Nigerian Academic Context
Nigerian academics face a few specific pressures that make a disciplined, checklist-driven approach especially valuable. University promotion frameworks frequently specify hard requirements around Scopus or Web of Science indexing, making formatting and journal-verification mistakes directly consequential to career progression rather than merely inconvenient. Many researchers also lack access to dedicated in-house editorial or publication support teams, leaving individual academics to navigate submission portals, formatting requirements, and reviewer correspondence largely alone. And the same publication pressure that drives genuine research output also makes Nigerian researchers a frequent target for predatory publishers — making a rigorous, unhurried verification step at every stage a genuine safeguard, not just good practice.
Stage 1 — Before You Start Writing
- Have you clearly articulated a specific, focused research question, rather than a broad topic area?
- Have you confirmed whether ethics approval is required for your study, and obtained it before data collection began?
- Have you identified potential co-authors and discussed authorship expectations and contribution roles early?
- Have you checked whether your institution or funder has a specific open-access or data-sharing policy that will affect your eventual journal choice?
- Have you registered your ORCID iD, if you don’t already have one, since many journals now require it at submission?
Stage 2 — Manuscript Preparation Checklist
- Does your manuscript follow a clear IMRaD structure (Introduction, Methods, Results, and Discussion), or the specific structure your discipline expects?
- Does your introduction clearly state your study’s specific, original contribution, not just its general topic area?
- Does your literature review build toward a clearly identified gap, rather than simply summarising prior studies?
- Is your methodology section detailed enough for another researcher to replicate your study?
- Are your results presented objectively, with interpretation reserved for the discussion section?
- Does your discussion section’s conclusions stay proportionate to what your actual data supports, avoiding overstated causal claims from correlational data?
- Have you clearly stated your study’s limitations honestly?
- Has the manuscript been checked for plagiarism and originality before proceeding further?
- Has the manuscript been professionally edited for clarity, grammar, and academic tone?
Stage 3 — Journal Selection and Verification Checklist
- Have you read several recent issues of your target journal, not just its stated aims and scope?
- Have you independently verified the journal’s current, active status directly on Scopus’s official source list or Web of Science, rather than trusting the journal’s own website claims?
- Have you checked whether the journal or publisher is a member of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)?
- Have you confirmed the editorial board members have real, traceable academic affiliations?
- Have you checked the journal’s typical review timeline against your own deadline (promotion review, graduation requirement, grant reporting)?
- Have you confirmed the article processing charge (APC), if any, and whether your institution or a grant can support it?
- Have you used an independent verification tool such as Think. Check. Submit. as a final legitimacy check?
Stage 4 — Formatting Compliance Checklist
- Have you downloaded and reviewed your target journal’s current “Instructions for Authors” or “Guide for Authors” page directly, rather than relying on memory of a previous journal’s requirements?
- Is your manuscript formatted in the exact citation style the journal requires (APA, Vancouver, Harvard, IEEE, or another convention)?
- Does your manuscript fall within the journal’s specified word count limits, including the abstract?
- Are your figures and tables formatted according to the journal’s specific file type, resolution, and labelling requirements?
- Have you used the journal’s required manuscript template, if one is specified?
- Have you included any mandatory reporting checklist your study type and target journal require (such as PRISMA, CONSORT, or STROBE)?
Stage 5 — Submission Package Checklist
- Have you drafted a concise, persuasive cover letter clearly stating your manuscript’s significance and fit for this specific journal?
- Have you confirmed the manuscript isn’t currently under review elsewhere, and stated this explicitly if required?
- Have you completed all required author declarations, including conflicts of interest, funding sources, and ethics approval statements?
- Have you obtained sign-off from all co-authors before submission?
- Have you prepared any required data availability statement?
- Have you double-checked that author names, affiliations, and your ORCID iD are entered correctly in the submission portal?
Stage 6 — After You Hit Submit
- Have you saved a confirmation of submission, including the manuscript ID and submission date?
- Have you calendared a reasonable follow-up point based on the journal’s stated typical review timeline, so you know when a status check becomes reasonable rather than premature?
- Have you informed all co-authors that the manuscript has been submitted, and to which journal?
- Have you kept a dated log of all correspondence with the journal, in case questions arise later in the process?
Stage 7 — Responding to Peer Review Checklist
- Have you read all reviewer comments fully before responding to any individual point?
- Have you addressed every single comment individually and explicitly in a structured, point-by-point response letter?
- Where you disagree with a specific comment, have you explained your reasoning respectfully and substantively, rather than simply declining the change without explanation?
- Have you clearly indicated where each change was made in the revised manuscript (page or line numbers, or tracked changes)?
- Have you had a colleague or professional editor review your response letter before resubmission?
- Have you confirmed all co-authors have reviewed and approved the revised manuscript before resubmission?
Stage 8 — Final Pre-Publication Checklist
- Have you carefully reviewed the publisher’s typeset proof for accuracy, checking author names, affiliations, and all data points against your original submission?
- Have you confirmed your ORCID iD is correctly linked to the final published record?
- Have you checked, once published, that the article appears correctly indexed in Scopus or your relevant target database?
- Have you updated your institutional repository or CV with the confirmed publication details?
- Have you shared the published work appropriately through professional academic networks, where permitted by the journal’s sharing policy?
The Complete Master Checklist (All Stages in One List)
For a single, scannable reference, here is the complete checklist condensed across all eight stages:
- Define a specific, focused research question
- Confirm and obtain any required ethics approval
- Agree authorship expectations with co-authors early
- Register an ORCID iD
- Structure the manuscript properly (IMRaD or discipline-specific equivalent)
- Clearly state the study’s original contribution
- Build the literature review toward a clear gap
- Ensure methodology is detailed enough for replication
- Keep results objective and interpretation in the discussion
- Ensure conclusions are proportionate to the actual data
- State limitations honestly
- Run a plagiarism and originality check
- Get the manuscript professionally edited
- Read recent issues of the target journal for genuine fit
- Independently verify the journal on Scopus, Web of Science, or DOAJ
- Confirm COPE membership and editorial board legitimacy
- Check review timeline against your own deadline
- Confirm article processing charges and funding coverage
- Run a final check via Think. Check. Submit.
- Review the journal’s current author guidelines directly
- Format citations in the required style
- Confirm word count compliance
- Format figures and tables to specification
- Use the required manuscript template
- Include any mandatory reporting checklist
- Draft a concise, persuasive cover letter
- Confirm the manuscript isn’t under review elsewhere
- Complete all author declarations
- Obtain co-author sign-off before submission
- Prepare a data availability statement
- Double-check author details and ORCID in the portal
- Save confirmation of submission
- Calendar a reasonable follow-up point
- Inform co-authors of submission
- Log all correspondence with the journal
- Read all reviewer comments fully before responding
- Address every comment individually and explicitly
- Explain reasoning where you disagree with a comment
- Indicate exactly where each change was made
- Have your response letter reviewed before resubmission
- Confirm co-author approval of the revised manuscript
- Review the typeset proof carefully
- Confirm ORCID linkage on the final record
- Confirm correct indexing once published
- Update your institutional repository and CV
- Share the published work through appropriate professional channels
Common Mistakes Nigerian Academics Make at Each Stage
- Skipping journal verification entirely, particularly under promotion or graduation deadline pressure, leaving researchers exposed to predatory publishing risk
- Relying on a previous journal’s formatting requirements without checking the current target journal’s specific, potentially different guidelines
- Submitting without complete co-author sign-off, occasionally creating disputes or delays discovered only after submission
- Responding to reviewer comments defensively or incompletely, weakening an otherwise strong revision
- Failing to follow through after acceptance, leaving published work poorly indexed or missing from institutional repositories that factor into promotion review
- Underestimating how long peer review genuinely takes, leading to unrealistic planning around promotion or graduation timelines
How We Help Nigerian Academics Move Through This Checklist Confidently
Working through every item on a checklist like this alone, while also managing a full teaching load or clinical practice, is genuinely difficult. Writers.ng provides structured support across every stage covered here:
- Manuscript structuring and academic editing, addressing the Stage 2 checklist items comprehensively
- Independent journal verification, covering every item in Stage 3 before you invest time or money in a specific target
- Formatting to your exact target journal’s guidelines, addressing Stage 4 in full
- Submission package preparation, covering cover letters, declarations, and portal accuracy checks from Stage 5
- Response-to-reviewers drafting support, guiding you through Stage 7’s requirements with a genuinely structured, professional approach
- Post-acceptance indexing follow-through, confirming Stage 8 is properly completed rather than assumed to happen automatically
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Do I need to complete every item on this checklist for every submission? Most items apply broadly, though some (like specific reporting checklists) only apply to certain study designs or journals. Treat it as a comprehensive reference to check against, adapting for your specific manuscript and target journal.
2. What’s the single most commonly skipped step? Independent journal verification, particularly checking a journal’s current, active status directly against Scopus or DOAJ, is frequently skipped under time pressure, despite being one of the most consequential checks on this list.
3. How do I register an ORCID iD? ORCID iDs are free and can be registered directly at orcid.org, providing a persistent digital identifier that distinguishes you from other researchers and increasingly integrates directly with journal submission systems.
4. What should I do if my manuscript is rejected after following this checklist carefully? Even a carefully prepared manuscript can be rejected for reasons related to fit or reviewer assessment of contribution. Review the feedback, address any legitimate concerns, and identify a better-matched alternative journal for resubmission.
5. How long should I wait before following up on my submission’s status? This should be based on the specific journal’s stated typical review timeline, available in their author guidelines — following up well before that stated window has elapsed is generally considered premature.
6. Is it normal to disagree with a peer reviewer’s comment? Yes, this happens regularly. What matters is explaining your reasoning respectfully and substantively in your response letter, rather than simply declining the requested change without justification.
7. Do I need co-author approval before every resubmission, not just the initial submission? Yes, best practice is to have all co-authors review and approve the manuscript at every substantial revision stage, not just the original submission, since content changes during revision.
8. What happens if my published article isn’t properly indexed in Scopus? This can happen due to a production or metadata error, and is worth actively checking and following up on with the publisher, since correct indexing directly affects whether the publication counts toward many institutional promotion requirements.
9. Can you help with just one specific stage of this checklist, rather than the full process? Yes, many researchers engage us for a specific stage — journal verification, formatting, or reviewer response support — rather than comprehensive end-to-end assistance.
10. Is my research and personal information kept confidential throughout this process? Yes. Every engagement with Writers.ng is handled with strict confidentiality, and your research and institutional details are never disclosed to third parties
Publishing successfully is rarely about any single decisive factor — it’s the accumulation of dozens of small, careful steps across manuscript preparation, journal verification, formatting, submission, and follow-through. Working through a structured checklist like this one, rather than relying on memory or assumption at each stage, is one of the most reliable ways to avoid the avoidable mistakes that most often delay or derail Nigerian academics on the path to publication.
Reach out to Writers.ng today if you’d like support working through any stage of this checklist. Share your manuscript’s current status and your target journal, and we’ll help you move forward with confidence.v