Common Mistakes That Delay Journal Publication
For many Nigerian researchers, academics, and PhD candidates, publication is the finish line that never seems to arrive. You’ve completed the research, written a solid manuscript, and submitted it with genuine confidence — only to face months of silence, a desk rejection with no real explanation, or a “revise and resubmit” that somehow drags on for over a year. If this feels familiar, you are far from alone, and in most cases, the delay isn’t about the quality of your underlying research. It’s about a handful of avoidable mistakes in how that research gets packaged, targeted, and submitted.
At WritersNG, Nigeria’s number one thesis and dissertation writing service, trusted by over 30,000 students and serving 200+ institutions nationwide, publication support is one of the services we provide most often to PhD candidates and academics preparing to extract journal articles from their thesis chapters. This guide breaks down the twelve mistakes we see most consistently — and exactly how to avoid each one.
1. Targeting the Wrong Journal From the Start
This is, by a significant margin, the most common reason manuscripts stall. Submitting a strong paper to a journal whose scope, audience, or methodological preferences don’t genuinely align with your work often results in a fast desk rejection, regardless of quality.
How to avoid it: Before writing your submission, read several recent issues of your target journal closely. Confirm that papers similar in topic, method, and theoretical framing to yours have actually been published there recently, not just that the journal’s stated scope sounds like a loose fit.
2. Ignoring the Journal’s Author Guidelines
Every journal publishes specific formatting requirements — word count limits, reference style, abstract structure, section headings — and many editors will desk-reject a manuscript that doesn’t comply, without ever sending it for review.
How to avoid it: Treat the author guidelines as a checklist, not a suggestion. Format your manuscript to match before submission, including reference style, figure/table formatting, and word count, rather than adapting a generic version across multiple journals.
3. A Weak or Generic Abstract
Editors and reviewers often decide whether to engage seriously with your manuscript based heavily on the abstract. A vague, overly broad, or poorly structured abstract can undersell genuinely strong research.
How to avoid it: Structure your abstract around a clear problem, your specific method, your key finding, and its significance — in that order — rather than a loose summary of your paper’s general topic.
4. Insufficient Positioning Within Current Literature
Reviewers frequently reject or request major revisions when a manuscript doesn’t clearly demonstrate awareness of the most recent, relevant literature in its specific subfield, even if the underlying research is sound.
How to avoid it: Ensure your literature review or introduction engages specifically with work published in the last three to five years, not just foundational older sources, and clearly articulates the precise gap your paper addresses.
5. Overstating Contributions or Findings
Reviewers are quick to flag claims that outpace what the data actually supports. Overstated contributions — claiming broad generalizability from a narrow sample, for instance — are a common trigger for skeptical, delay-inducing reviewer pushback.
How to avoid it: Frame your contribution precisely and honestly, explicitly acknowledging the boundaries of what your specific data and method can support.
6. Statistical or Methodological Errors
Reviewers with genuine subject-matter expertise will catch methodological weaknesses — incorrect statistical tests, inadequate sample justification, unaddressed confounding variables — that can trigger a rejection or a lengthy, difficult revision cycle.
How to avoid it: Have your methodology and analysis reviewed by someone with genuine statistical expertise before submission, ideally someone outside your immediate research team who can catch issues you may be too close to the work to notice.
7. Poor Response to Reviewer Comments
A “revise and resubmit” decision is often good news, but many researchers delay their own publication further by responding to reviewer comments defensively, incompletely, or after months of procrastination.
How to avoid it: Respond to every reviewer comment individually and specifically, even ones you disagree with — explain your reasoning respectfully rather than ignoring the point. Submit your revision within the requested timeframe wherever possible, since extended delays can result in editors treating your paper as a fresh submission.
8. Language and Clarity Issues
For many Nigerian researchers submitting to international journals, language clarity — not research quality — becomes the primary source of reviewer frustration and delay, particularly when dense, unclear prose obscures otherwise strong findings.
How to avoid it: Have your manuscript professionally edited for clarity and academic tone before submission, distinct from a basic grammar check, focused specifically on making complex ideas easy for a reviewer to follow quickly.
9. Submitting to Predatory or Low-Quality Journals
In the pressure to publish quickly, some researchers submit to journals with minimal or no genuine peer review. This can result in a paper that technically “publishes” fast but carries little academic credibility, and can actively harm a researcher’s reputation and future publication prospects.
How to avoid it: Verify a journal’s legitimacy before submitting — check whether it’s indexed in reputable databases, review its editorial board’s genuine academic credentials, and be wary of journals promising unusually fast publication for a fee with minimal review.
10. Missing or Incomplete Ethical Clearance Documentation
Many journals, particularly in health sciences and social sciences, require clear documentation of ethical approval for research involving human subjects. Missing or incomplete documentation here is a common and entirely avoidable cause of delay or rejection.
How to avoid it: Secure and clearly document your institutional ethical clearance before beginning data collection, and ensure your manuscript explicitly states this approval, including the approving body and reference number where required.
11. Unresolved Co-Authorship and Conflict-of-Interest Issues
Disputes or ambiguity over co-authorship order, or undisclosed conflicts of interest, can stall a submission indefinitely, particularly when a co-author has concerns that surface only after the paper is already under review.
How to avoid it: Resolve authorship order and contribution expectations with all co-authors before submission, and disclose any relevant conflicts of interest transparently within the manuscript itself.
12. Going Silent After a Rejection
A rejection, even a discouraging one, is not the end of the road — but many researchers lose months or years of momentum by setting a rejected manuscript aside indefinitely rather than revising and resubmitting elsewhere.
How to avoid it: Treat reviewer feedback from a rejection as genuinely useful input, even from a journal you won’t resubmit to. Revise based on that feedback and identify a better-fitting journal promptly, rather than letting the manuscript stall.
13. Missing or Weak Cover Letters
Many researchers skip the cover letter entirely, or submit a generic one that doesn’t tell the editor anything useful. A weak cover letter is a missed opportunity to frame your paper’s significance before an editor even opens the manuscript.
How to avoid it: Use your cover letter to briefly state your paper’s core contribution, confirm it hasn’t been published or is under review elsewhere, and note why it fits this specific journal — not a recycled generic template sent to every outlet.
14. Not Verifying Journal Indexing Before Submission
Publishing in a journal that isn’t properly indexed can quietly undermine years of research effort — the paper “exists” but carries little weight for promotion, funding applications, or academic credibility, and Nigerian institutions increasingly scrutinize this closely for tenure and promotion purposes.
How to avoid it: Confirm indexing status directly before submitting, not after. The major indexes and lists worth checking include:
- Scopus — one of the most widely recognized citation databases, used heavily in Nigerian university promotion criteria
- Web of Science (Clarivate) — another major citation index, often required alongside or instead of Scopus depending on your institution
- DOAJ (Directory of Open Access Journals) — a curated whitelist of legitimate open-access journals, useful for verifying open-access outlets specifically
- NUC-recognized journal lists — some Nigerian universities maintain their own approved or recommended journal lists via departmental or faculty guidance, worth checking directly with your institution
- Journal Citation Reports (JCR) — provides impact factor data for indexed journals, useful for comparing journals within your specific subfield
A journal claiming “international indexing” without specifying which database, or listing obscure, unverifiable indexes, is a signal worth investigating further before you submit.
15. Ignoring Article Processing Charges (APCs) Until Late in the Process
Many open-access journals charge a publication fee, sometimes substantial, only disclosed clearly after a paper has already been accepted. Researchers who haven’t budgeted for this can face a difficult, delay-inducing scramble to secure funds, or worse, an accepted paper that never gets published because the fee can’t be paid.
How to avoid it: Check a journal’s APC policy before submission, not after acceptance. If your research was grant-funded, confirm whether the grant covers publication costs; if self-funded, factor this into your target journal selection from the start, since APCs can range from token amounts to figures well beyond what many independent researchers can absorb without warning.
16. Underestimating Formatting and Citation Software Errors
Reference management software like Zotero, Mendeley, or EndNote can introduce subtle formatting errors — duplicate entries, incorrect journal abbreviations, inconsistent capitalization — that slip through unnoticed until a sharp-eyed reviewer or editor flags them, sometimes triggering an entirely avoidable round of correction requests.
How to avoid it: Manually spot-check your reference list against your target journal’s specific style guide before submission, rather than trusting citation software output blindly. Pay particular attention to consistency in author name formatting, journal title abbreviations, and DOI inclusion.
17. Missing Data Availability Statements
An increasing number of journals now require a data availability statement, specifying whether and how your underlying data can be accessed by other researchers. Omitting this, or providing a vague or non-compliant statement, is an increasingly common cause of desk rejection at journals that have adopted this requirement.
How to avoid it: Check your target journal’s specific data availability policy before submission, and prepare a clear, compliant statement — whether that means committing to share data on request, depositing it in a recognized repository, or explaining legitimate restrictions such as participant confidentiality.
18. Poor Handling of the Revision Timeline
Even researchers who respond thoughtfully to reviewer comments sometimes underestimate how long a thorough, well-executed revision genuinely takes, leading to rushed, incomplete resubmissions that trigger a second, frustrating round of major revisions.
How to avoid it: Treat your revision timeline as seriously as your original writing timeline. Build in enough time to properly address each comment, run any additional analysis reviewers have requested, and have the revised manuscript reviewed by a colleague or editor before resubmission, rather than rushing to meet an artificial internal deadline.
A Deeper Look: Understanding Predatory Journal Red Flags
Because mistake #9 (submitting to predatory journals) carries such serious long-term consequences for a researcher’s credibility, it’s worth examining the warning signs in more detail:
Unusually fast, guaranteed publication timelines. Legitimate peer review takes genuine time. A journal promising publication within days or a couple of weeks, regardless of your paper’s content, is very unlikely to be conducting real peer review.
Aggressive, unsolicited email solicitation. Legitimate journals rarely cold-email researchers aggressively soliciting submissions, particularly with flattering, generic language that doesn’t reference your actual specific research area.
Vague or unverifiable editorial board listings. Check whether the named editorial board members are genuinely affiliated with the institutions listed, and whether they appear to have any real involvement — some predatory journals list academics without their knowledge or consent.
Unclear or hidden fee structures. Legitimate journals disclose publication fees transparently upfront. Journals that reveal fees only after acceptance, or bury fee information in hard-to-find pages, warrant real caution.
Publishing an implausibly broad range of unrelated topics. A journal claiming to cover everything from nuclear physics to social work within a single generalist outlet is a common predatory pattern, since legitimate journals typically maintain a coherent, specific scope.
No clear physical address or verifiable publisher information. Legitimate publishers are transparent about their organizational details; predatory operations often obscure this information or provide addresses that don’t correspond to genuine offices.
A Glossary of Key Publication Terms
- Desk Rejection: A rejection issued by the editor before the manuscript is sent out for peer review, typically due to poor fit or guideline non-compliance.
- Peer Review: The process by which independent experts in your field evaluate your manuscript’s quality and validity before a publication decision is made.
- Revise and Resubmit (R&R): An editorial decision inviting you to revise your manuscript based on reviewer feedback and resubmit for further consideration, rather than an outright acceptance or rejection.
- Impact Factor: A metric reflecting how frequently a journal’s articles are cited on average, often used as a proxy for journal prestige within a field.
- Open Access (OA): A publishing model in which the final article is freely available to readers, often funded through an author-paid Article Processing Charge.
- Article Processing Charge (APC): A fee charged to authors, typically for open-access publication, covering the costs of editorial and publishing services.
- Preprint: A version of a manuscript shared publicly, often via a preprint server, before or during the formal peer review process.
- Predatory Journal: A publication that charges fees while providing minimal or no genuine peer review, prioritizing profit over academic rigor.
- Data Availability Statement: A required statement in many journals specifying how and whether other researchers can access the underlying data behind your findings.
- Corresponding Author: The author designated as the primary point of contact with the journal throughout the submission and publication process.
A Realistic Publication Timeline
| Phase | Typical Duration | Key Milestone |
|---|---|---|
| Journal selection and manuscript preparation | 2–4 weeks | Manuscript formatted to target journal guidelines |
| Initial submission and editorial screening | 1–4 weeks | Manuscript sent for peer review or desk-rejected |
| Peer review | 2–6 months (field-dependent) | Reviewer comments received |
| Revision (if R&R) | 4–8 weeks | Revised manuscript resubmitted |
| Second review round (if required) | 1–3 months | Final decision reached |
| Production and publication | 1–3 months | Article formally published |
Total time from initial submission to publication commonly ranges from six months to well over a year, which is precisely why starting the process early — ideally while still finishing your final thesis chapters — matters so much for PhD candidates working toward a publication requirement.
Preprints: A Strategic Option Worth Considering
For researchers in fields where preprint culture is well established, sharing a preprint version of your manuscript before or during formal peer review can offer real advantages: establishing a public timestamp on your work, inviting informal feedback from the wider research community, and increasing early visibility for your findings.
Before using a preprint server, confirm your target journal’s policy. Most major journals now accept prior preprint posting, but this isn’t universal, and some fields or specific outlets still treat preprints as prior publication that could complicate formal submission.
Choose a recognized preprint server relevant to your field, rather than an obscure or unverified platform, to ensure your preprint carries genuine credibility and visibility.
How Nigerian Institutional Context Shapes Publication Priorities
Publication requirements and incentives vary meaningfully depending on your specific Nigerian institution and career stage:
For PhD candidates, many Nigerian universities now require at least one publication, often in a Scopus-indexed journal, before final thesis submission or graduation clearance — making early, strategic journal targeting essential rather than a late-stage afterthought.
For academics pursuing promotion, most Nigerian universities apply specific, often quite detailed criteria around journal indexing status and quantity of publications within defined periods, making it worth confirming your specific department’s current promotion criteria before committing significant time to any single journal.
For researchers pursuing grant-funded work, funding bodies increasingly expect open-access publication as a condition of funding, which should factor directly into both journal selection and APC budgeting from the earliest planning stages.
Choosing Between Multiple Suitable Journals
Sometimes the challenge isn’t finding a journal that fits — it’s narrowing down several plausible options. A few factors worth weighing:
Turnaround reputation. Some journals are known within a field for notably faster or slower review cycles than others of similar prestige. Where timing genuinely matters — a graduation deadline, a grant reporting requirement — this can be a legitimate deciding factor.
Acceptance rate versus prestige trade-off. Highly prestigious journals often carry lower acceptance rates and longer review times. Weigh whether your specific career stage and timeline genuinely benefit from aiming highest first, or whether a strong, credible mid-tier journal serves your immediate needs better.
Open access versus subscription model. Open-access journals typically charge an APC but offer wider, unrestricted readership; subscription journals are usually free to publish in but limit access to institutional subscribers. Consider your field’s norms and your own funding situation when weighing this trade-off.
Special issues and calls for papers. Many journals periodically run themed special issues with calls for papers closely aligned to specific topics. If your research fits a live call, this can sometimes offer a faster, more targeted review path than a standard general submission.
Journal’s typical citation and readership patterns within your specific subfield. A journal that’s prestigious in a broad discipline may still have limited visibility among the specific specialists most likely to cite and build on your particular contribution.
Overcoming Submission Procrastination
For many researchers, especially those juggling full-time careers alongside academic work, the biggest obstacle to publication isn’t rejection — it’s simply never submitting in the first place. A few practical patterns that help:
Set a specific submission date, not a vague intention. “I’ll submit sometime this quarter” rarely happens; “I will submit by the 15th” is far more likely to.
Separate “finished enough to submit” from “perfect.” Many strong papers sit unsubmitted for months because researchers keep refining details reviewers may never even raise. Peer review exists precisely to catch what needs further work — use it, rather than trying to eliminate every possible objection before ever submitting.
Break manuscript preparation into concrete, scheduled steps — finalizing the abstract, formatting references, writing the cover letter — rather than treating “prepare the manuscript” as one large, indefinitely postponable task.
Find an accountability structure, whether that’s a writing group, a colleague, or a professional editor or coordinator who expects specific deliverables by specific dates. External accountability consistently helps researchers who work well independently in most areas of their career still move stalled manuscripts forward.
A Quick Self-Check Before You Submit
| Question | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Have I read recent issues of this exact journal? | Confirms genuine scope and audience fit |
| Does my manuscript match the author guidelines precisely? | Prevents desk rejection on formatting grounds |
| Does my abstract clearly state problem, method, finding, and significance? | Shapes the editor’s and reviewer’s first impression |
| Have I engaged with literature from the last 3–5 years? | Demonstrates current, credible positioning |
| Are my claims fully supported by my actual data? | Prevents reviewer skepticism and pushback |
| Has my methodology been reviewed by a genuine statistical expert? | Catches errors before reviewers do |
| Is my prose clear and accessible to a reviewer reading quickly? | Prevents clarity issues from obscuring strong findings |
| Is this journal genuinely indexed and reputable? | Protects your academic credibility |
| Is my ethical clearance documented and referenced? | Prevents avoidable delay or rejection |
| Have co-authorship and conflicts of interest been resolved and disclosed? | Prevents late-stage disputes |
| Does my cover letter clearly state my paper’s contribution and journal fit? | Frames the editor’s first impression before they open the manuscript |
| Have I confirmed the journal’s indexing status and APC policy? | Protects academic credibility and prevents late funding scrambles |
| Have I manually checked my reference list against the journal’s style guide? | Catches citation software errors reviewers will notice |
| Does my paper include a compliant data availability statement, if required? | Prevents desk rejection at journals with this requirement |
How WritersNG Supports Journal Publication
Publication support is one of our core services for PhD candidates and academics across Nigeria, structured specifically around the mistakes outlined above:
Journal targeting. We help you identify journals genuinely aligned with your paper’s scope, method, and theoretical framing, based on their actual recent publication history.
Manuscript reformatting. We reformat your paper to match your target journal’s specific author guidelines, including reference style, section structure, and word count.
Abstract and framing review. We help sharpen your abstract and introduction to clearly communicate your problem, method, finding, and significance.
Statistical and methodological review. Our analysts review your methodology and data analysis for accuracy and defensibility before submission.
Language and clarity editing. We provide professional academic editing focused specifically on clarity and readability for a reviewer audience.
Reviewer response support. We help you draft clear, respectful, and complete responses to reviewer comments during a revise-and-resubmit cycle.
Every engagement is priced transparently in Naira based on your specific manuscript and target journal. Get a free, no-obligation quote here.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does the average journal publication process take? This varies enormously by field and journal, but a realistic range for most peer-reviewed journals is anywhere from a few months to over a year from submission to final decision, including revision cycles.
What’s the difference between a desk rejection and a reviewer rejection? A desk rejection happens before your paper is sent for peer review, usually due to poor journal fit or guideline non-compliance. A reviewer rejection happens after genuine peer review has assessed the substance of your work.
How do I know if a journal is predatory? Check whether it’s indexed in reputable databases, review its editorial board’s genuine credentials, and be cautious of journals promising unusually fast publication for a fee with minimal or unclear peer review.
Can WritersNG help me extract a publishable article from my thesis? Yes, this is one of our core PhD support services — reformatting thesis chapters into standalone manuscripts and helping identify appropriate target journals.
What if my paper has already been rejected once? We can help you revise based on the feedback received and identify a better-fitting journal for resubmission, rather than letting the manuscript stall indefinitely.
Do you help with responding to reviewer comments during a revise-and-resubmit? Yes, we support drafting clear, complete, and respectful responses to reviewer feedback as part of our publication support service.
Is my research and manuscript kept confidential during this process? Completely. Confidentiality is central to how we operate, and this is especially important given the premium placed on originality in academic publishing.
Do most Nigerian universities require Scopus-indexed publications specifically? Requirements vary by institution and department, but many Nigerian universities now expect PhD candidates and academics pursuing promotion to publish in Scopus-indexed or similarly recognized journals. It’s worth confirming your specific department’s current criteria directly.
Should I post a preprint of my manuscript before formal submission? This can offer real advantages like establishing a public timestamp and early visibility, but confirm your target journal’s specific preprint policy first, since this isn’t universally accepted across every field and outlet.
How much do Article Processing Charges typically cost? APCs vary enormously by journal and publisher, ranging from token amounts to figures well beyond what many independent researchers can absorb without prior planning. Always check a journal’s specific APC policy before submission.
How do I get started with publication support? Reach out via WhatsApp or our website with your manuscript details, target field, and current stage in the process, and we’ll respond with a personalized quote, often within the same day.
Ready to Move Your Research Toward Publication?
Publication delays are almost always fixable once you know exactly where they’re coming from. As Nigeria’s number one thesis and dissertation writing service, trusted by over 30,000 students and available 24/7, WritersNG is ready to help you avoid these eighteen common mistakes and move your manuscript toward genuine, credible publication.
Get your free, no-obligation quote today →
Prefer to chat directly? Message us on WhatsApp now and speak with a publication support coordinator in real time.